A Review of Surgical Education Fellowships in the United States
Authors:
- Caitlin SilvestriCSCaitlin Silvestri
- Maya L. HuntMHMaya L. Hunt
- Connie Y. GanCGConnie Y. Gan
- Michael A. KochisMKMichael A. Kochis
- Sarah LundSLSarah Lund
- Joshua RoshalJRJoshua Roshal
- Darian HoaglandDHDarian Hoagland
- Ariana NaasehANAriana Naaseh
- Tejas S. SatheTSTejas S. Sathe
- Rebecca MoreciRMRebecca Moreci
- Nicole BrooksNBNicole Brooks
- Riley BrianRBRiley Brian
Preprint
Abstract
Purpose: Surgical education fellowships emerged to address the growing need for formal surgical education training. However, little is known about fellowship structure, curricula, and outcomes. This lack of transparency creates challenges for residents choosing programs, institutions developing new fellowships, and existing programs evaluating their outcomes. Method: Authors identified 28 United States-based surgical education fellowships and distributed a survey to representatives (directors or fellows) from each program evaluating program structure, educational opportunities, research infrastructure, teaching experiences, and mentorship. Responses were analyzed using descriptive statistics. Results: Nineteen fellowship programs (68% response rate) participated. The majority of programs offered full funding (84%). Program length varied from 1 to 2 years, most commonly with one fellow per year. Few (16%) required completion of an advanced degree during the fellowship. The majority mandated teaching (84%) and simulation (89%) responsibilities, though time commitments varied. Most programs (84%) required fellows to attend national conferences. Over half (53%) had an Education PhD advisor within the department, and 63% provided free access to statisticians. Leadership structures varied, with 74% having a single fellowship director. Among directors, 80% were surgical specialists, while all non-surgical directors held Education PhDs. Dedicated faculty time equivalents for directors varied widely. Conclusions: Our findings highlight significant heterogeneity across U.S. surgical education fellowships. Transparency about fellowship structures could improve prospective fellow decision-making and guide future program development. Further research should focus on the long-term outcomes of fellowship graduates and the impact of accreditation on fellowship success.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- A novel approach for the advancement of surgical education: the collaboration of surgical education fellows (CoSEF)Global Surgical Education - Journal of the Association for Surgical Education, 2022
- Outcome assessment of medical education fellowships in emergency medicineAEM Education and Training, 2021
- Does Intentional Support of Degree Programs in General Surgery Residency Affect Research Productivity or Pursuit of Academic Surgery? A Multi-Institutional StudyJournal of Surgical Education, 2020
- A Multifaceted Research Engagement Program Improved the Academic Productivity of General Surgery ResidentsJournal of Surgical Education, 2020
- Developing and refining a surgical curriculumSurgery, 2020
- Success in Academic Surgery: Developing a Career in Surgical Education2019
- Exploring Advanced Degrees2013
- Practical skills teaching in contemporary surgical education: how can educational theory be applied to promote effective learning?The American Journal of Surgery, 2012
- Educational scholarship as a route to academic promotion: a depiction of surgical education scholarsThe American Journal of Surgery, 2006
- A systematic review of faculty development initiatives designed to improve teaching effectiveness in medical education: BEME Guide No. 8Medical Teacher, 2006