“Circumstantial Determinants”: An Efficient Approach to Reaching People in Need of HIV Prevention?
Preprint
Abstract
HIV prevention and testing programmes primarily reach people who self-refer or attend routine health services. Higher-risk individuals are missed if they are healthy, underestimate their risk of infection or under-report sexual risk-behaviours. We assess a new approach to address limitations in existing programmes by targeting HIV services on “Circumstantial Determinants” (CDs) of HIV risk – the social circumstances, settings, and norms associated with behaviours that increase risk of HIV acquisition. Data on potential CDs and sexual behaviour were collected in a population survey in Zimbabwe in 2018/19 (N=9141). HIV-negative individuals reporting ≥1 sexual risk-behaviours were defined as the’priority population’ for HIV prevention. For each sex, six circumstantial determinants were associated with being in the priority population (aOR≥1.30; p≤0.01). Reach and efficiency of CDs (and combinations) were calculated; ROC curve algorithms evaluated their ability to identify priority population membership; and HIV prevention condom cascades were compared between CD-defined priority population subgroups. Example findings include that targeting men at bars and beerhalls could reach 48.5% of the priority population and 25.1% of lower-risk men. These percentages increase to 77.1% and 53.7% if men with poor mental health, no religious affiliation, negative social capital, or living on agricultural estates are also targeted. Targeting women with poor mental health could reach 32.0% of the priority population and 21.3% of lower-risk women. Targeting additional circumstantial determinants increases these percentages to 54.1% and 37.5%, respectively. Cascade barriers to condom use differed between CD-defined subgroups. The Circumstantial Determinants approach demonstrates proof-of-concept potential to strengthen HIV prevention services.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risky sexual behavior and associated factors among people with severe mental illness in Africa: A systematic review and meta-analysisJournal of Affective Disorders, 2025
- Risk scores for predicting HIV incidence among adult heterosexual populations in sub‐Saharan Africa: a systematic review and meta‐analysisJournal of the International AIDS Society, 2022
- Accuracy of HIV Risk Perception in East Zimbabwe 2003–2013AIDS and Behavior, 2018
- Effect of clients Strategic Index Case Testing on community-based detection of HIV infections (STRICT study)International Journal of Infectious Diseases, 2018
- Prevalence and Associations of Psychological Distress, HIV Infection and HIV Care Service Utilization in East ZimbabweAIDS and Behavior, 2017
- Realizing the Potential for HIV Self-TestingAIDS and Behavior, 2014
- The Influence of Religion on Sexual HIV RiskAIDS and Behavior, 2014
- Evaluation of a Peer Network-Based Sexual Risk Reduction Intervention for Men in Beer Halls in Zimbabwe: Results from a Randomized Controlled TrialAIDS and Behavior, 2011
- HIV Risk Behaviours and their Relationship to Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) Among Men Who Have Multiple Female Sexual Partners in Cape Town, South AfricaAIDS and Behavior, 2010
- A pilot study for an HIV prevention programme among commercial sex workers in Bulawayo, ZimbabweSocial Science & Medicine, 1990