Often Overlooked Problems with Handoffs

Authors:

Abstract
Over the last decade, increased attention has been focused on the transfer of care between clinical teams (“handoffs”) as a potentially modifiable factor in preventing adverse patient outcomes. Handoffs occurring in the perioperative setting may be particularly prone to error due to the need to exchange complex information and an environment that emphasizes efficiency and rapid turnovers. In such environments, use of a handoff protocol increases the duration of a handoff only slightly, while decreasing missed surgical information and improving nursing satisfaction.1 A 2012 meta-analysis of best practices for perioperative handoffs by Segall et al.2 identified more than 500 articles on this topic. Interestingly, all focused solely on the transfer of patient care from the operating room (OR) to the intensive care unit (ICU). As anesthesiologists and intensivists, we feel that perioperative handoffs in transfer of patients from the ICU to the OR have been overlooked, but are equally important. To further evaluate this topic, we performed a comprehensive PubMed, Cochrane, and Embase database search of subsequent investigations since 2012 using the same search terms as Segall et al.2 Specifically, we included the following terms: handover, handoff and patient transfer, and combinations of the terms postoperative, anesthesia, postanesthesia, surgery, OR, ICU, critical care, intensive care, surgical intensive care, admission, communication, and team. Although more than 80 articles were identified, none addressed the transfer of care from the ICU to the OR. Reasons for the lack of research on ICU to OR handoffs in the literature are unclear. The “reverse handoff” from ICU to the OR is potentially even more important than from OR to ICU because ICU to OR transfers often occur in unstable patients scheduled for emergent or urgent surgical procedures and magnify the potential risk to patient safety. While studies identifying errors in ICU to OR handoffs are lacking, we are confident that anecdotal experiences abound. The authors are familiar with several vignettes where care was compromised due to the lack of a comprehensive ICU to OR handoff. One example involved a patient with severe left ventricular dysfunction 3 days after cardiac surgery who developed bilateral femoral artery thrombosis and required urgent thrombectomy. On induction, the patient developed severe hypotension and remained hemodynamically unstable despite vasopressor and inotrope use. Case review later identified that the patient had been weaned off norepinephrine only an hour before returning to the OR. In another example, an ICU patient in end-stage renal failure was receiving q48h gentamicin. Because dosing was intermittent, gentamicin was thus not listed on the medication list on days it was not being given. The patient was taken to the OR on a day she was not scheduled to receive gentamicin. Although her day-of-surgery gentamicin level was already supratherapeutic, she received another dose in the OR. The potential for errors to occur in the OR from an incomplete ICU handoff can also occur with care that may be routine in the ICU but not immediately apparent to the anesthesiologist. Examples of such “wouldn’t know unless you ask” therapies include the use of “sigh” breaths to maintain oxygenation during mechanical ventilation or unusual reactions to intermittently dosed sedatives. In all of these circumstances, the lack of a “nonstandardized” handoff meaningfully affects patient outcomes and thus warrants a structured approach. Although the anesthesiology team has the ultimate responsibility to obtain a complete patient history, vital information may still be missed. Intubated, unstable, or critically ill patients may not always be a reliable source of information. Under these circumstances, a detailed clinician-to-clinician handoff is necessary.

This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit: