Confidence and accuracy of lineup selections and rejections: Postdicting rejection accuracy with confidence.
Authors:
- R. C. L. LindsayRLR. C. L. Lindsay
- Natalie KalmetNKNatalie Kalmet
- Jaime LeungJLJaime Leung
- Michelle I. BertrandMBMichelle I. Bertrand
- James D. SauerJSJames D. Sauer
- Melanie SauerlandMSMelanie Sauerland
- 1 September 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition
- Vol. 2 (3) , 179-184
Abstract
Correlation and calibration approaches show meaningful, positive confidence-accuracy relations for witnesses making selections from lineups, but rarely for rejections ( Brewer & Wells, 2006; Sauerland & Sporer, 2009 ). This disparity may reflect the difference between selecting a single photo versus rejecting a set of photos. Participants ( N = 101) in two experiments made selections from and rejections of lineups in situations requiring either a single confidence rating about a single face (typical of “choosers”) or a single confidence rating about multiple faces (typical of “nonchoosers”). Mean confidence ratings were significantly higher for accurate versus inaccurate decisions for both selections and rejections when decisions were based on single faces. Single decisions about multiple faces produced no significant difference in confidence between correct and incorrect rejections but a significant difference for selections.Keywords
Funding Information
- Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Choosing versus Rejecting: The Impact of Goal-Task Compatibility on Decision ConfidenceSocial Cognition, 2009
- On the diagnosticity of multiple-witness identifications.Law and Human Behavior, 2008
- Post-decision confidence, decision time, and self-reported decision processes as postdictors of identification accuracyPsychology, Crime & Law, 2007
- Suspect/Foil Identification in Actual Crimes and in the Laboratory: A Reality Monitoring Analysis.Law and Human Behavior, 2005
- Multiple Independent Identification Decisions: A Method of Calibrating Eyewitness Identifications.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2004
- Postdictors of eyewitness errors: Can false identifications be diagnosed?Journal of Applied Psychology, 2000
- Eyewitness identification accuracy, confidence, and decision times in simultaneous and sequential lineups.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1993
- Post‐dicting eyewitness accuracy: Confidence, decision‐times and person descriptions of choosers and non‐choosersEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 1992
- Juror Underutilization of Eyewitness Nonidentifications: A Test of the Disconfirmed Expectancy Explanation1Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 1989
- Juror underutilization of eyewitness nonidentifications: Theoretical and practical implications.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1986