Evaluation of a 23-cm Minimum Length Limit for Black and White Crappies in a Small South Dakota Impoundment

Authors:
  • TBTimothy J. Bister
    Timothy J. Bister
  • DWDavid W. Willis
    David W. Willis
  • AKAllen D. Knapp
    Allen D. Knapp
  • TSTodd R. St. Sauver
    Todd R. St. Sauver

Abstract
The South Dakota Department of Game, Fish, and Parks instituted a 23-cm minimum length limit for black crappie Pomoxis nigromaculatus and white crappie P. annularis in Lake Alvin on 1 January 1996 because an undesirable size and age structure indicated that these pop- ulations were being overharvested. Crappies were sampled annually using trap (modified fyke) nets from 1992 to 1999. Mean catch per unit effort (fish/net night) was higher in the postregulation years (1996-1999) than in the preregulation years (1992-1995) for both species. The mean length of age-3 fish in the postregulation years was not different from that of the 1995 baseline for either species. The relative stock density of 23-cm crappies did not increase after implementation of the length limit. Limited prey availability, which was inferred from the negative trend of relative weight with respect to length, was the likely reason that larger crappies did not appear. The 23- cm minimum length limit was removed on 1 January 2000 to give anglers the opportunity to harvest smaller crappies. Minimum length limits for crappies Pomoxis spp. have only recently been used as a tool by fisheries managers and had not been implemented by the South Dakota Department of Game, Fish, and Parks (SDGFP) prior to 1996. Generally, minimum length limits should only be applied to crappie populations of low to moderate density that have moderate to fast growth (by the stan- dards of the region) and whose size structure has been negatively affected by angler harvest. Min- imum length limits should not be applied to high- density, slowly growing crappie populations (Colvin 1991; Allen and Miranda 1995) because they would compound the problem of overpop- ulation by further increasing crappie density and intraspecific competition. The success of mini- mum length limits for crappies has been mixed. Positive results have been reported by Colvin (1991) and Webb and Ott (1991), while negative results have been reported by Hale et al. (1999), Larson et al. (1991), Reed and Davies (1991), and Boxrucker (1999). The size structure of the populations of black

This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit: