Participation and Flexibility in Informal Processes: Cautions from the Divorce Context
Authors:
- Howard S. ErlangerHEHoward S. Erlanger
- Elizabeth ChamblissECElizabeth Chambliss
- Marygold S. MelliMMMarygold S. Melli
- 1 January 1987
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Society Review
- Vol. 21 (4) , 585-604
Abstract
Based on open-ended interviews with the parties and lawyers in twenty-five informally settled divorce cases, this study finds that the informal process is often contentious, adversarial, and beyond the perceived control of one or both parties. Although settlement in some cases reflects flexibility, party participation, and true agreement, in most cases it reflects unequal financial resources, procedural support, or emotional stamina. Parties report settling issues such as child support according to nonlegal, situational factors—particularly their relative impatience to finalize the divorce—and mutual satisfaction with settlement terms is low. Our findings raise questions about the assumed value of informal settlement. However, we recognize that informal processing of divorce is structurally and institutionally inevitable (with or without evidence of its desirability), and we suggest that reform efforts must ultimately recognize both the inevitability and the limits of informal process.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing the Effects of Case Characteristics and Settlement Forum on Dispute Outcomes and ComplianceLaw & Society Review, 1987
- What do Dutch Lawyers actually do in Divorce Cases?Law & Society Review, 1986
- Law and Strategy in the Divorce Lawyer's OfficeLaw & Society Review, 1986
- The Relative Significance of Disputing Forum and Dispute Characteristics for Outcome and ComplianceLaw & Society Review, 1986
- The Small Claims Court: A Reconceptualization of Disputes and an Empirical InvestigationLaw & Society Review, 1984
- Reformers v. Abolitionists: Some Notes for Further Research on Plea BargainingLaw & Society Review, 1979
- Plea Bargaining: A Critic's RejoinderLaw & Society Review, 1979
- The Problem of Voluntariness and Coercion in the Negotiated PleaLaw & Society Review, 1979
- Mandatory Sentencing and the Abolition of Plea Bargaining: The Michigan Felony Firearm StatuteLaw & Society Review, 1979