Fortalezas e fragilidades do atendimento nas Unidades Básicas de Saúde tradicionais e da Estratégia de Saúde da Família pela ótica dos usuários
Open Access
- 1 September 2013
- journal article
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Texto & Contexto - Enfermagem
- Vol. 22 (3) , 780-788
Abstract
This study was aimed at analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of the Family Healthcare Strategy and the Traditional Primary Healthcare Unit from the perspective of users, based on the assessment dimensions proposed by Starfield in relation to primary healthcare. A qualitative approach was used in this research, carried out through interviews with users of these distinct healthcare models. The weaknesses and strengths of these models of healthcare are similar regarding the access, gateway, healthcare services offered at different levels of technological density and their articulation. For the users of the Family Healthcare Strategy, the bond, longitudinality and focus on the family occur in a more effective way. As for the professional team, the users of the traditional Primary Healthcare unit are more satisfied than the users of the Family Healthcare Strategy, since these do not have all their needs met due to the fact that this service only offers access to a general practitioner. It can, therefore, be concluded that there is a need to make changes to the two models of healthcare services. Descriptors: Primary health care. Unified Health System. Quality of health care. RESUMEN Este estudio propone analizar fortalezas y limitaciones de Estrategia de Salud Familiar y Unidad Básica de Salud Tradicional desde la perspectiva de usuarios, basándose en dimensiones de evaluación de atención primaria de salud propuesta por Starfield. La investigación es cualitativa, basada en entrevistas con usuarios que utilizan las diferentes modalidades de atención a la salud. Las debilidades y fortalezas de las dos formas son similares en términos de acceso, puerta de entrada, prestación de servicios de salud con diferentes niveles de complejidad y su articulación. Para los usuarios de Estrategia de Salud Familiar , el vínculo, longitudinalidad y el enfoque familiar ocurren de manera más eficaz. Sin embargo, considerando el equipo profesional, los usuarios de Unidad Básica de Salud Tradicional están más satisfechos que los usuarios de la Estrategia de Salud Familiar, porque sólo refieren que un médico general es suficiente. Al parecer, existe necesidad de ajustes en ambas modalidades de atención. Descriptores: Atención primaria de salud. Sistema Único de Salud. Calidad de la atención de salud. INTRODUCTION The Unified Health System ( Sistema Único de Saúde - SUS) caused a major breakthrough by proposing a healthcare concept that considers the various determinants and constraints involved in the health/disease process. Thus, health has been considered as a social product and as good quality of life. It also proposes that healthcare follows the principles of universal access, holistic care, equity, decentralization and social participation, 1 which focus on primary healthcare. Primary healthcare is defined by the Ministry of Health (MS) as "individual or collective actions, developed in the first level of the healthcare services system, focused on the promotion of health, prevention of diseases, treatment and rehabilitation". 2:44 Primary healthcare is a gateway to the system for all new needs and problems, is focused on people, and also serves to coordinate or integrate the care provided in another level of healthcare. 3 It is in primary healthcare that resources are organized and optimized, both basic and specialized, and that the connection and accountability for the healthcare needs of people, families and community are maintained. The current healthcare proposal of the SUS strongly differs from the model that, for many decades, prevailed in our reality and has not been able to meet the real needs of the population, which involves individual care focused on the complaint, the biological aspects, the division of care and has the hospital as the main healthcare scenario. The necessary change has posed a great challenge and, in order to face it, the Ministry of Health has been using some strategies, with emphasis on the Community Health Agents Program (PACS), since 1991, and the Family Healthcare Program (PSF), since 1994. 2 The Family Healthcare Strategy (ESF), in particular, has been considered as the most comprehensive and instigating proposal and, therefore, is subject to further investments, expectations and questions in relation to its effectiveness. Throughout the two decades of efforts put into changing the healthcare model, some advancement concerning the guiding principles of SUS and the strategies proposed could be witnessed. However, there are still some difficulties, such as the division in the work process and in the relationship among professionals, the lack of complementarity between primary healthcare and the referral system, poor interaction within teams and lack of skills to deal with the subjective dimension of healthcare practices, low investment in the training of workers and in the promotion of co-management and also the disregard to users' rights. 4 A study that analyzes the ESF, taking into consideration its possibilities and limits based on publications related to its performance, points to a slight superiority of this strategy over the traditional primary healthcare units, leaving theoretical and operational challenges that still need to be faced in relation to its implementation. 5 In establishing a framework that is comprehensive and effective for the study of primary healthcare, some authors have used 2 the dimensions of primary healthcare assessment, 3 which include access, gateway, bond or longitudinality, list of services, coordination or integration of services, family focus, orientation to the community and professional training. 6 These dimensions represent important indicators of primary healthcare quality, being used to analyze the potentiality of the different models found in healthcare services. Upon observing the implantation process of the ESF in a medium-sized city, which also experiences the model of Traditional Primary Healthcare Unit (UBST) with the incorporation of PACS, some advancements could be noted, as well as some remaining difficulties. Thus, it is important to examine in which aspects this strategy is contributing in relation to attending to the real needs of the population and in relation to the implementation of a healthcare model that proposes access, bonding and integrality as its main guiding axes. It is therefore proposed in this study to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of the ESF and the UBST, from the perspective of users, based on the dimensions of primary healthcare quality. 3 METHOD A qualitative approach was used in the present research. The field of study is limited to the primary healthcare units of a city located in the Center-West of the state of Sao Paulo, which currently has 220,000 inhabitants. According to the management documents of the Municipal Health Council, the healthcare model has been gradually reoriented to a progressive transformation, in order to implement the ESF, guided by the principles of SUS. Currently, the city has 12 UBSTs and 30 Family Healthcare Units (USFs). 7 Despite having incorporated the PACS, there was little change in the work process of the professionals in the UBSTs of the city. The team meetings are sporadic and it is not always possible to get everyone to participate. Generally, the USFs of the city meet the minimum requirements for implementation, according to the recommendations of the Ministry of Health, in relation to physical structure, minimum team formation and development of the primary national programs. These units are installed in areas where the population has higher socio-economic needs, assisting approximately 110,000 people, which represent around 50% of the city's population. In order to carry out this study, four UBSs and 12 USFs were randomly selected, being one UBS and three USFs from each region of the city (North, South, East and West). Data were collected through interviews with semi structured questions, based on the dimensions access, gateway, bond or longitudinality, list of services, coordination or integration of services, family focus, guidance to the community and professional training. 3 Concerning the selection of participants, this sought to include adult people of various age groups, with or without illnesses. Thirty-two interviews were performed, being 16 with users of the UBSTs and 16 of the ESF, which were fully recorded and transcribed. The participants were contacted at the healthcare units by an experienced interviewer, before or after treatment, through convenience sampling. Data collection took place in November and December 2010. Data analysis was based on dialectical hermeneutics and, after obtaining the statements of the participants, they were organized into a table that displayed the data per participant and question, so as to show the empirical facts and order the data. Secondly, the data were classified into central ideas and this involves understanding that the data do not exist by themselves, but they are developed based on theoretically grounded questions. Therefore, the relevant structures of the participants' statements were identified and grouped into themes, in which broader meanings are addressed, moving towards a summary through the development of possible meanings. 8-9 Then, the final analysis was undertaken, when the data collected were articulated with the theoretical framework of the research, through a dialectical movement which considers the divergence, the contradiction, the concrete and the abstract, the particular and the general, in order to reach the concrete thought. 9 This research had the approval of the City Health Department and of the Research Ethics Committee in relation to research involving human beings at the Faculdade de Medicina de Marilia, registration number 682/08, and all participants who agreed to participate in the study signed an Informed Consent Form. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION In analyzing the interviews, based on the dimensionsKeywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Condições limitadoras para a integralidade do cuidado à criança na atenção básica de saúdeTexto & Contexto - Enfermagem, 2011
- Revisão sistemática sobre o conceito de acesso nos serviços de saúde: contribuições do planejamentoCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2010
- Ensaio histórico-conceitual sobre a Atenção Primária à Saúde: desafios para a organização de serviços básicos e da Estratégia Saúde da Família em centros urbanos no BrasilCadernos de Saude Publica, 2008
- A política pública de saúde brasileira: representação e memória social de profissionaisCadernos de Saude Publica, 2008
- Necessidades de saúde: uma análise da produção científica brasileira de 1990 a 2004Interface - Comunicação, Saúde, Educação, 2007
- Atenção Básica em Saúde: comparação entre PSF e UBS por estrato de exclusão social no município de São PauloCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2006
- As várias abordagens da família no cenário do programa/estratégia de saúde da família (PSF)Revista Latino-Americana de Enfermagem, 2004
- Acesso e acolhimento aos usuários em uma unidade de saúde de Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, BrasilCadernos de Saude Publica, 2003
- Promoção da saúde e qualidade de vidaCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2000
- Modelos tecno-assistenciais em saúde: da pirâmide ao círculo, uma possibilidade a ser exploradaCadernos de Saude Publica, 1997