Economic and biological costs of cardiac imaging
Open Access
- 25 May 2005
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Cardiovascular Ultrasound
- Vol. 3 (1) , 13
Abstract
Medical imaging market consists of several billion tests per year worldwide. Out of these, at least one third are cardiovascular procedures. Keeping in mind that each test represents a cost, often a risk, and a diagnostic hypothesis, we can agree that every unnecessary and unjustifiable test is one test too many. Small individual costs, risks, and wastes multiplied by billions of examinations per year represent an important population, society and environmental burden. Unfortunately, the appropriateness of cardiac imaging is extra-ordinarily low and there is little awareness in patients and physicians of differential costs, radiological doses, and long term risks of different imaging modalities. For a resting cardiac imaging test, being the average cost (not charges) of an echocardiogram equal to 1 (as a cost comparator), the cost of a CT is 3.1x, of a SPECT 3.27x, of a Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance imaging 5.51x, of a PET 14.03x, and of a right and left heart catheterization 19.96x. For stress cardiac imaging, compared with the treadmill exercise test equal to 1 (as a cost comparator), the cost of stress echocardiography is 2.1x and of a stress SPECT scintigraphy is 5.7x. Biohazards and downstream long-term costs linked to radiation-induced oncogenesis should also be considered. The radiation exposure is absent in echo and magnetic resonance, and corresponds to 500 chest x rays for a sestamibi cardiac stress scan and to 1150 chest x rays for a thallium scan. The corresponding extra-risk in a lifetime of fatal cancer is 1 in 2000 exposed patients for a sestamibi stress and 1 in 1000 for a thallium scan. Increased awareness of economic, biologic, and environmental costs of cardiac imaging will hopefully lead to greater appropriateness, wisdom and prudence from both the prescriber and the practitioner. In this way, the sustainability of cardiac imaging will eventually improve.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lack of radiological awareness among physicians working in a tertiary-care cardiological centreInternational Journal of Cardiology, 2005
- Role of Noninvasive Testing in the Clinical Evaluation of Women With Suspected Coronary Artery DiseaseCirculation, 2005
- ACCF/AHA/HRS/SCAI Clinical Competence Statement on Physician Knowledge to Optimize Patient Safety and Image Quality in Fluoroscopically Guided Invasive Cardiovascular ProceduresCirculation, 2005
- Clinical indications for cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR): Consensus Panel report?European Heart Journal, 2004
- Informed consent and communication of risk from radiological and nuclear medicine examinations: how to escape from a communication infernoBMJ, 2004
- Sustainability of medical imagingBMJ, 2004
- Doctors' knowledge of radiation exposure: questionnaire study: TABLE 1BMJ, 2003
- ACC/AHA 2002 guideline update for the management of patients with chronic stable angina—summary articleJACC, 2003
- Do Physicians Correctly Estimate Radiation Risks from Medical Imaging?Archives of Environmental Health: An International Journal, 2003
- Multicentre aneurysm screening study (MASS): cost effectiveness analysis of screening for abdominal aortic aneurysms based on four year results from randomised controlled trialBMJ, 2002