Processual Comparative Sociology
- 1 March 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociological Theory
- Vol. 30 (1) , 51-65
Abstract
Charles Tilly’s work on process analysis offers a methodological approach to comparative-historical sociology that can be considered paradigmatic. Yet the approach has been widely criticized for lack of rigor. This paper maintains that the problem lies in insufficient clarification of the approach’s central concept: mechanism. Once scrutinized, the concept reveals a tension between its connotation and its denotation. This can be addressed in two ways: either by maintaining what the concept connotes according to Tilly but limiting what it denotes (thus limiting the paradigm’s scope conditions) or by limiting what it connotes and maintaining what it was intended by Tilly to denote (thus maintaining wide scope conditions). Elucidating the possibilities of processual comparison is particularly important for comparative-historical sociology because the subfield rests upon processual presuppositions.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Charles Tilly and American PragmatismThe American Sociologist, 2010
- Causal Mechanisms: Yes, But…Comparative Political Studies, 2010
- A Pragmatist Theory of Social MechanismsAmerican Sociological Review, 2009
- The Realist Approach to Explanatory Mechanisms in Social SciencePhilosophy of the Social Sciences, 2009
- An Admirable Call to Improve, But Not Fundamentally Change, Our Collective Methodological PracticesQualitative Sociology, 2008
- What Is Organizational Imprinting? Cultural Entrepreneurship in the Founding of the Paris OperaAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2007
- When mechanistic models explainSynthese, 2006
- How Does It Work?Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 2004
- Social mechanisms without black boxes1998
- Mechanism and ExplanationPhilosophy of the Social Sciences, 1997