State-mediated “hierarchy of diversities” and the freedom of individual self-identification: Towards a dynamic liberal model of muticulturalism
Author:
- 1 January 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in New Global Development
- Vol. 15 (1) , 36-51
Abstract
The contemporary choice is between society structured as a set of ethnically determined communities and the liberal society, which acknowledges the uniqueness of each individual as well as his/her personal way of self-identification. There are two points which are extremely important in the discussion: first, no culture is ever homogeneous, and co-existence of different streams is an inevitable feature of social reality; second, culture contributes to action not by supplying the ultimate values toward which the action is oriented, but by shaping a repertoire of habits, skills and styles, from which people construct ‘strategies of action’. According to the liberal view, individuals, even if they belong to one ethnic group, seek to make their own choices, to form their own beliefs and judgments, while individual self-identification can be predetermined not only by one's belonging to the ethnic group, but also by one's gender, political views, etc. The idea of multiracial democracy contradicts the fundamental human freedom of civic self-identification, at least as it is defined in its individualistic version. As it is hardly possible to combine the conception of the multiracial democracy with the ideals of liberalism, a dynamic model of liberal multiculturalism seems to be the optimal solution. To the extent that each power elite represents a case of monocultural domination, it is only the independent civil society as opposed to the state power elite that can advance the ideal of liberal multiculturalism. This paper arose out of an ongoing theoretical debate on the principles of intercultural bridgemaking in the YES project of the Hebrew University NCJW Research Institute for Innovation in Education and its discussions by the project staff. The author would like to thank liana Silber, Hillel Warman, Shalva Weil, Baruch Kimmerling and especially Rita Sever and Ezra Kopelowitz for their most helpful commentaries on the previous drafts of the paper.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- The impact of immigration on the United States social security systemNew Global Development, 1997
- New Global Welfare: Excursus on Post-Industrial DevelopmentNew Global Development, 1996
- Cultural Citizenship and Educational DemocracyCultural Anthropology, 1994
- Liberalism, Multiculturalism, and Minority ProtectionSocial Theory and Practice, 1994
- The Ethiopian Jewish Experience as Blacks in IsraelJournal of Black Studies, 1993
- Culture's Public FacePublic Culture, 1993
- "Balan ced Multiculturalism" an d the Challenge of Peaceful Coexistence in Pluralistic SocietiesPsychology and Developing Societies, 1991
- Modes of Civil SocietyPublic Culture, 1990
- Inter-Ethnic MarriagesInternational Journal of Comparative Sociology, 1982
- The Adaptation of Cultural Ties to Economic DevelopmentAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 1974