When can we expect negative effects of plant diversity on community biomass?
Open Access
- 30 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 113 (8) , 1955-1969
Abstract
Although experiments overwhelmingly show biodiversity increases ecosystem functioning, relationships in natural communities are more variable. This raises the question of under which conditions negative diversity effects might occur. We argue that plant communities containing more core species that stably coexist should have higher biomass production. However, variation in numbers of transient species, whose abundances fluctuate strongly and which cannot stably coexist, may not consistently affect biomass. Distinguishing changes in core and transient species richness is critical. For instance, recent attempts to use novel causal modelling approaches have implied negative effects of biodiversity on community biomass. However, we find these approaches also result in negative relationships when applied to experiments, where we know there is a positive causal effect of biodiversity. We suggest that transient species contribute disproportionately to the variation in biodiversity isolated in these models. We highlight the need for improved approaches to analysing data from ‘real‐world’ communities and call for increased attempts to compare results with experimental systems. Synthesis . Understanding the functional consequences of biodiversity loss is critical but we need to be clear about what type of biodiversity change we are measuring and to focus on the loss of stably coexisting core species.Keywords
Funding Information
- Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (310030_215442)
This publication has 90 references indexed in Scilit:
- Partitioning the effects of plant diversity on ecosystem functions at different trophic levelsEcological Monographs, 2022
- Removing subordinate species in a biodiversity experiment to mimic observational field studiesGrassland Research, 2022
- Fluctuation‐independent niche differentiation and relative non‐linearity drive coexistence in a species‐rich grasslandEcology, 2019
- The prevalence and impact of transient species in ecological communitiesEcology, 2018
- Towards the Integration of Niche and Network TheoriesTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2018
- A structural approach for understanding multispecies coexistenceEcological Monographs, 2017
- The Overlooked Role of Facilitation in Biodiversity ExperimentsTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2017
- Intransitivity is infrequent and fails to promote annual plant coexistence without pairwise niche differencesEcology, 2017
- Sown species richness and realized diversity can influence functioning of plant communities differentlyThe Science of Nature, 2014
- Variation in U.S. traffic safety policy environments and motor vehicle fatalities 1980–2010Public Health, 2013