Private schooling and admission to medicine: a case study using matched samples and causal mediation analysis
Open Access
- 20 August 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 15 (1) , 136
Abstract
Are applicants from private schools advantaged in gaining entry to degrees in medicine? This is of international significance and there is continuing research in a range of nations including the USA, the UK, other English-speaking nations and EU countries. Our purpose is to seek causal explanations using a quantitative approach. We took as a case study admission to medicine in the UK and drew samples of those who attended private schools and those who did not, with sample members matched on background characteristics. Unlike other studies in the area, causal mediation analysis was applied to resolve private-school influence into direct and indirect effects. In so doing, we sought a benchmark, using data for 2004, against which the effectiveness of policies adopted over the past decade can be assessed. Private schooling improved admission likelihood. This did not occur indirectly via the effect of school type on academic performance; but arose directly from attending private schools. A sensitivity analysis suggests this finding is unlikely to be eliminated by the influence of an unobserved variable. Academic excellence is not a certain pathway into medicine at university; yet applying with good grades after attending private school is more certain. The results of our paper differ from those in an earlier observational study and find support in a later study. Consideration of sources of difference from the earlier observational study suggest the causal approach offers substantial benefits and the consequences in the causal study for gender, ethnicity, socio-economic classification and region of residence provide a benchmark for assessing policy in future research.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Socio-economic predictors of performance in the Undergraduate Medicine and Health Sciences Admission Test (UMAT)BMC Medical Education, 2013
- The future of medical education: a Canadian environmental scanMedical Education, 2010
- A general approach to causal mediation analysis.Psychological Methods, 2010
- Widening access? Characteristics of applicants to medical and dental schools, compared with UCASBritish Dental Journal, 2009
- Why are there so few working‐class applicants to medical schools? Learning from the success storiesMedical Education, 2009
- Middle class education strategies and residential segregation in AthensJournal of Education Policy, 2006
- Medical education challenges in South AfricaMedical Education, 1999
- Prospective study of the disadvantage of people from ethnic minority groups applying to medical schools in the United Kingdom.BMJ, 1989
- Admission for medicine in the United Kingdom: a structural model of background factorsMedical Education, 1986
- The social class of medical studentsMedical Education, 1982