Punitiveness of electronic monitoring: Perception and experience of an alternative sanction
Open Access
- 16 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Probation
- Vol. 13 (3) , 262-281
Abstract
Electronic monitoring (EM) serves as an alternative sanction to incarceration. An important aspect that remains only scarcely debated in the literature is EM’s punitiveness and, more specifically, exactly how punitive EM is in comparison to different forms of incarceration. Responding to this gap, we propose a systematic meta-analysis of relevant studies that scrutinizes and compares different studies on EM and its punitive effects (or perceptions of its degree of punitiveness) in relation to incarceration. Ultimately, there is no simple and straightforward answer: EM’s level of punitiveness differs with the various sociodemographic variables of respondents included in the studies and the various characteristics of the penal system. It is necessary to assess the degree of punitiveness of EM to determine the conditions under and terms with which it should be applied, for example, as a humane substitute for incarceration or as an additional pain of the penal system.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Punishment at home: Offenders’ experiences with electronic monitoringEuropean Journal of Criminology, 2013
- Electronic Monitoring of Offenders: An Ethical ReviewScience and Engineering Ethics, 2013
- Progress or More of the Same? Electronic Monitoring and Parole in the Age of Mass IncarcerationCritical Criminology, 2012
- The impact of curfews and electronic monitoring on the social strains, support and capital experienced by youth gang members and offenders in the west of ScotlandCriminology & Criminal Justice, 2011
- Attitudes about electronic monitoring: Minority and majority racial group differencesJournal of Criminal Justice, 2009
- Is good-time appropriate for offenders on electronic monitoring?: attitudes of electronic monitoring directorsJournal of Criminal Justice, 2000
- Understanding the Experience of House Arrest with Electronic Monitoring: An Analysis of Quantitative and Qualitative DataInternational Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 2000
- Attitudes Toward Electronic Monitoring Among Monitored Offenders and Criminal Justice StudentsJournal of Offender Rehabilitation, 1999
- Toward the development of punishment equivalencies: Male and female inmates rate the severity of alternative sanctions compared to prisonJustice Quarterly, 1999
- The Severity of Intermediate SanctionsJournal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 1995