Four years comparative follow‐up evaluation of community‐based, step‐down, and residential specialist psychodynamic programmes for personality disorders
- 26 July 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy
- Vol. 24 (6) , 1331-1342
Abstract
Although the fulcrum of service provision for personality disorder (PD) has shifted from hospital‐based to psychodynamically‐ and cognitively‐oriented outpatient programmes, very few studies have attempted to compare specialist moderate intensity outpatient programmes with specialist high‐intensity residential models, or to explore whether a period of inpatient treatment may be necessary to improve outcome and prognosis. In this article, we prospectively compare changes over a 4‐year period in 3 groups of patients with personality disorders (N = 162) treated in a specialist community‐based (CBP, N = 30), a step‐down (RT‐CBP, N = 87), and a specialist residential programme (RT, N = 45) in psychiatric distress, deliberate self‐injury, and suicide attempt using multilevel modelling and multivariate logistic regression analyses. The results showed that percentages of early‐dropout were significantly different (p = .0001) for the 3 programmes (CBP = 13.4%, RT‐CBP = 10.2%, and RT = 41.4%). A significant interaction between treatment model and time was found for psychiatric distress (p = .001), with CBP and RT‐CBP achieving more marked changes (g = 1.20 and g = 0.68, respectively) compared to RT (g = 0.30) at 48‐month follow‐up. CBP and RT‐CBP were found to significantly reduce impulsive behaviour (deliberate self‐injury and suicide attempt) compared to RT. Severity of presentation was not found to be a significant predictor of outcome. Long‐term RT showed no advantage over long‐term CBP, either as stand‐alone or as step‐down treatment. Replication may be needed to confirm generalizability of results, and a number of limitations in the study design may moderate the inferences that can be drawn from the results.Keywords
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Impact of clinical severity on outcomes of mentalisation-based treatment for borderline personality disorderThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 2013
- Three‐week inpatient Cognitive Evolutionary Therapy (CET) for patients with personality disorders: Evidence of effectiveness in symptoms reduction and improved treatment adherencePsychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 2012
- Effectiveness of Outpatient, Day Hospital, and Inpatient Psychotherapeutic Treatment for Patients with Cluster B Personality DisordersPsychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 2010
- The struggle to establish a research culture in the psychotherapy hospital: Reflections from the Cassel Hospital experienceBulletin of the Menninger Clinic, 2009
- Prediction of Medium-Term Outcome in Cluster B Personality Disorder following Residential and Outpatient Psychosocial TreatmentPsychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 2007
- The McLean Study of Adult Development (MSAD): Overview and Implications of the First Six Years of Prospective Follow-UpJournal of Personality Disorders, 2005
- Can psychoanalytic research integrate and improve knowledge for clinical practice?The Scandinavian Psychoanalytic Review, 2005
- Is Hospitalization Useful for Suicidal Patients with Borderline Personality Disorder?Journal of Personality Disorders, 2004
- Evaluation of Intensive Inpatient Treatment of Patients With Severe Personality DisordersPsychiatric Services, 2000
- Swimming against the Tide? A Review of the Therapeutic CommunityAustralian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 1997