The effects of communicating uncertainty around statistics on public trust: an international study
Preprint
Abstract
A growing body of research indicates that transparent communication of statistical uncertainty around facts and figures does not undermine credibility. However, the extent to which these findings apply in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic—rife with uncertainties—is unclear. In a large international survey experiment, (Study 1; N = 10,519) we report that communicating uncertainty around COVID-19 statistics in the form of a numeric range (vs. no uncertainty) may lead to slightly lower trust in the number presented but has no impact on trust in the source of the information. We also report the minimal impact of numeric uncertainty on trust is consistent across estimates of current or future COVID-19 statistics (Study 2) and figures relating to environmental or economic research, rather than the pandemic (Study 3). Conversely, we find imprecise statements about the mere existence of uncertainty without quantification can undermine both trust in the numbers and their source – though effects vary across countries and contexts. Communicators can be transparent about statistical uncertainty without concerns about undermining perceptions of their trustworthiness, but ideally should aim to use numerical ranges rather than verbal statements.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Royal Society Open Science, 10 (11), 230604.
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Stakeholders’ rationales for representing uncertainties of biotechnological researchPublic Understanding of Science, 2016
- Climate Projections and Uncertainty CommunicationTopics in Cognitive Science, 2015
- “Probably true” says the expert: how two types of lexical hedges influence students’ evaluation of scientificnessEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education, 2015
- Uncertainty forecasts improve weather-related decisions and attenuate the effects of forecast error.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2012
- Communication of Uncertainty Regarding Individualized Cancer Risk EstimatesMedical Decision Making, 2010
- The weirdest people in the world?Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2010
- Frequency or Probability? A Qualitative Study of Risk Communication Formats Used in Health CareMedical Decision Making, 2001
- MESSAGE FORMAT AND AUDIENCE VALUES: INTERACTIVE EFFECTS OF UNCERTAINTY INFORMATION AND ENVIRONMENTAL ATTITUDES ON PERCEIVED RISKJournal of Environmental Psychology, 2000
- GPOWER: A general power analysis programBehavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers, 1996
- Presenting Uncertainty in Health Risk Assessment: Initial Studies of Its Effects on Risk Perception and TrustRisk Analysis, 1995