Climate-Smart Irrigation: Multiple Perspectives for Better Decision-Making
Open Access
Abstract
Climate-smart irrigation (CSI) links agricultural productivity and livelihoods with adaptation, resilience, and, where feasible, mitigation. Assessing CSI is complicated by the different purposes of irrigation decisions and the scales at which their consequences emerge. This focused integrative review distinguishes actors from the decision perspectives through which success is judged. It identifies six non-hierarchical perspectives: user/livelihood, service/operational, resource stewardship/allocation, public policy/societal, public/development investment, and commercial/market. Three decision situations illustrate their interactions. Irrigation efficiency may benefit farmers without increasing basin water availability; solar-powered irrigation may reduce operational emissions while changing groundwater-use incentives; and scarcity allocation involves competing needs, rights, and resource risks. These situations show why success in one decision context does not necessarily indicate climate-smart performance. The review examines the boundaries and strength of supporting evidence, distinguishing demonstrated outcomes from indirect evidence and enabling conditions. The six perspectives are not criteria that every irrigation decision must satisfy. Their value lies in revealing dependencies, consequences, and evidence beyond the immediate decision position. CSI can therefore be assessed more clearly by examining what irrigation decisions achieve, for whom, under what conditions, at what scale, and with what climate relevance.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do grid-connected solar irrigation pumps help promote groundwater sustainability?: Evidence from IndiaEnergy Nexus, 2026
- Solar irrigation and just energy transitions in agriculture: Insights from evaluation of Gujarat's SKY programEnergy Policy, 2026
- What is behind water user satisfaction with irrigation organizations´ performance? An empirical analysis under different water scarcity conditionsAgricultural Water Management, 2024
- Barriers to the uptake of solar-powered irrigation by smallholder farmers in sub-saharan Africa: A reviewEnergy Strategy Reviews, 2024
- Resolving the paradoxes of irrigation efficiency: Irrigated systems accounting analyses depletion-based water conservation for reallocationAgricultural Water Management, 2023
- Climate-smart irrigation and responsible innovation in South Asia: A systematic mappingAMBIO, 2023
- Challenging ‘one size fits all’: Continued use of sprinkler irrigation in a state‐led drip irrigation project in MoroccoIrrigation and Drainage, 2022
- Addressing the Groundwater Governance Challenge2016
- Performance Assessment Of Collective Irrigation In Water Users’ Associations Of Calabria (Southern Italy)Irrigation and Drainage, 2015
- Re-visiting what we know about Irrigation Management Transfer: A review of the evidenceAgricultural Water Management, 2015