Are Dissertations Trustworthy Enough? The case of Turkish Ph.D. Dissertations on Social Studies Education
Open Access
- 1 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Participatory Educational Research (Per) in Participatory Educational Research
- Vol. 9 (3) , 344-361
Abstract
Although there is an increasing number of studies concentrating upon education, some researchers have revealed that most studies, including qualitative studies in education, have methodological issues. One of the most common mistakes and neglected issues in qualitative studies is not to ensure the trustworthiness of the research, which indeed is an important component for the rigor of the study. The main purpose of this study is to examine how researchers ensure the trustworthiness of Ph.D. dissertations in social studies education. Document analysis was employed in the study. I examined 197 Ph.D. dissertations belonging to years 2002 and 2020 as well as to the field of social studies education which were obtained from the National Dissertation Center of Turkish Higher Education Council. I used the deductive coding and analysis approach in order to examine dissertations. The study results revealed that no trustworthiness strategy was used or reported in nearly half of Ph.D. dissertations that were conducted in the field of social studies education. Researchers mostly preferred to use validity and reliability terms, which are highly criticized by some scholars as to the paradigm of qualitative orientations. Besides, while some trustworthiness strategies such as peer debriefing and external audit were mainly used, others such as negative case analysis and stepwise replication were not used or reported in any dissertation. Some recommendations were made considering the study results and discussions at the end of the study.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Qualitative Content AnalysisSage Open, 2014
- Qualitative Research in Education: The Origins, Debates, and Politics of Creating KnowledgeEducational Studies, 2013
- Establishing rigour in qualitative radiography researchRadiography, 2010
- Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research MethodQualitative Research Journal, 2009
- Appraising the trustworthiness of qualitative studies: Guidelines for occupational therapistsAustralian Occupational Therapy Journal, 2007
- Establishing Trustworthiness in Qualitative Research in Social WorkQualitative Social Work, 2006
- Content Analysis in Mass Communication: Assessment and Reporting of Intercoder ReliabilityHuman Communication Research, 2002
- Rigor or rigor mortisAdvances in Nursing Science, 1993
- Rigor in Qualitative Research: The Assessment of TrustworthinessAmerican Journal of Occupational Therapy, 1991
- An Overview of Social Studies Dissertations, 1977–1982Theory & Research in Social Education, 1985