COMPARISON OF INTERNATIONAL AUDIT STANDARDS FOR INFORMATION SECURITY WITH AUTOMATION PERSPECTIVES
Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- journal article
- Published by Borys Grinchenko Kyiv University in Cybersecurity: Education, Science, Technique
- Vol. 3 (31) , 579-588
Abstract
This study presents a comparative analysis of three widely recognized audit-related international standards such as ISO 19011, ISO/IEC 27007, and ISA 200, aimed at identifying the most suitable methodological foundation for further research on the automation of audit management processes. The motivation for this work stems from the increasing complexity of audit activities in modern organizations and the growing need for structured, reproducible, and automatable audit procedures. A review of recent publications shows that comparative studies of audit standards remain limited, particularly in the context of information security and artificial intelligence, which underscores the relevance and originality of the present research. The evaluation methodology developed in this study incorporates a multi-criteria approach that considers academic visibility, general web presence, and the recency of each standard. Quantitative data from Google Scholar and Google Search were normalized using a dedicated formula to ensure comparability across different metrics. According to the calculated results, ISA 200 achieved the highest overall score due to its wide citation base and broad applicability across financial audit domains, while ISO/IEC 27007 received the lowest score because of its narrower scope and lower visibility. Despite ISA 200’s quantitative advantage, the qualitative assessment demonstrates that ISO 19011 provides the most structured, universal, and adaptable audit framework, built around a clearly defined PDCA lifecycle. This structure is particularly advantageous for audit automation, as it offers a systematic sequence of actions that can be formalized and later integrated into AI-driven decision-making systems. Therefore, ISO 19011 is identified as the most appropriate standard for guiding future research on automated audit methodologies and for developing intelligent tools capable of supporting audit planning, execution, and follow-up activities.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Systematic Review of Voluntary Cybersecurity Standards and FrameworksInternational Journal of Information Security, 2025
- Assessing Wi-Fi Security Protocols: A Study of Dictionary Attack PerformanceBaltic Journal of Modern Computing, 2025
- INFORMATION RETRIEVAL AND DEANONYMIZATION IN THE TASKS OF EARLY DETECTION OF POTENTIAL ATTACKS ON CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURECybersecurity: Education, Science, Technique, 2024
- Comparison of Tools for Web-Application Brute ForcingTheoretical and Applied Cybersecurity, 2022
- Review of Cybersecurity Audit Management and Execution Approaches2019
- Information technology audit for management evaluation using COBIT and IT security (Case study on Dishubkominfo of North Maluku Provincial Government, Indonesia)2016
- Formalization of the IT Audit Management Process2012
- Information Audit: Towards common standards and methodologyBusiness Information Review, 2012
- Security audit: a case study [information systems]2004
- Are You Being Fooled? Audit Quality and Quality of GovernmentSSRN Electronic Journal, 2004