Predictive performance of universal termination of resuscitation rules in an Asian community: are they accurate enough?
- 6 December 2013
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Emergency Medicine Journal
- Vol. 32 (4) , 318-323
Abstract
Introduction Prehospital termination of resuscitation (TOR) rules have not been widely validated outside of Western countries. This study evaluated the performance of TOR rules in an Asian metropolitan with a mixed-tier emergency medical service (EMS). Methods We analysed the Utstein registry of adult, non-traumatic out-of-hospital cardiac arrests (OHCAs) in Taipei to test the performance of TOR rules for advanced life support (ALS) or basic life support (BLS) providers. ALS and BLS-TOR rules were tested in OHCAs among three subgroups: (1) resuscitated by ALS, (2) by BLS and (3) by mixed ALS and BLS. Outcome definition was in-hospital death. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value and decreased transport rate (DTR) among various provider combinations were calculated. Results Of the 3489 OHCAs included, 240 were resuscitated by ALS, 1727 by BLS and 1522 by ALS and BLS. Overall survival to hospital discharge was 197 patients (5.6%). Specificity and PPV of ALS-TOR and BLS-TOR for identifying death ranged from 70.7% to 81.8% and 95.1% to 98.1%, respectively. Applying the TOR rules would have a DTR of 34.2–63.9%. BLS rules had better predictive accuracy and DTR than ALS rules among all subgroups. Conclusions Application of the ALS and BLS TOR rules would have decreased OHCA transported to the hospital, and BLS rules are reasonable as the universal criteria in a mixed-tier EMS. However, 1.9–4.9% of those who survived would be misclassified as non-survivors, raising concern of compromising patient safety for the implementation of the rules.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Females of childbearing age have a survival benefit after out-of-hospital cardiac arrestResuscitation, 2013
- The Hazards of Providing Care in Emergency Vehicles: An Opportunity for ReformPrehospital Emergency Care, 2009
- EMS in Taiwan: Past, present, and futureResuscitation, 2009
- Independent Evaluation of an Out‐of‐hospital Termination of Resuscitation (TOR) Clinical Decision RuleAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2008
- Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2008 UpdateCirculation, 2008
- Validation of a Rule for Termination of Resuscitation in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac ArrestNew England Journal of Medicine, 2006
- Comparison of Termination-of-Resuscitation Guidelines for Basic Life Support: Defibrillator Providers in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac ArrestAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Derivation of a Termination‐of‐resuscitation Guideline for Emergency Medical Technicians Using Automated External DefibrillatorsAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2002
- T ERMINATION OF R ESUSCITATION IN THE P REHOSPITAL S ETTING FOR A DULT P ATIENTS S UFFERING N ONTRAUMATIC C ARDIAC A RRESTPrehospital Emergency Care, 2000
- Decision making in prehospital sudden cardiac arrestAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1986