Two instructional designs for dialogic citizenship education: An effect study
- 1 September 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 79 (3) , 439-461
Abstract
Background Despite the renewed interest in citizenship education, relatively little is known about effective ways to realize citizenship education in the classroom. In the literature on citizenship education, dialogue is considered to be a crucial element. However, there is very little, if any, empirical research into the different ways to stimulate dialogue. Aim The main aim of this study is to arrive at an understanding of how citizenship education can be integrated in history classes. The focus is on the effect of a dialogic approach to citizenship education on students' ability to justify an opinion on moral issues. Sample Four hundred and eighty‐two students in the eighth grade of secondary education. Methods Two curriculum units for dialogic citizenship education were developed and implemented. The two curriculum units differed in the balance between group work and whole‐class teaching. Students' ability to justify an opinion was assessed by means of short essays written by students on a moral issue. The effectiveness of both curriculum units was compared with regular history classes. Results Students who participated in the lessons for dialogic citizenship education were able to justify their opinion better than students who participated in regular history lessons. The results further show a positive effect of the amount of group work involved. Conclusion The results of this study indicate that a dialogic approach to citizenship education as an integral part of history classes helps students to form a more profound opinion about moral issues in the subject matter. In addition, group work seems to be a more effective method to implement dialogue in the classroom than whole‐class teaching.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Creating critical‐democratic citizenship education: empowering humanity and democracy in Dutch educationCompare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 2007
- The moral roots of citizenship: reconciling principle and character in citizenship educationJournal of Moral Education, 2006
- Moral education and character education: their relationship and roles in citizenship educationJournal of Moral Education, 2006
- Values in teachingTeachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 2003
- The Moral Reasoning and Scientific Argumentation of Gifted AdolescentsJournal of Secondary Gifted Education, 2002
- Discourse Patterns and Collaborative Scientific Reasoning in Peer and Teacher-Guided DiscussionsCognition and Instruction, 1999
- Ethical Reasoning: Real and SimulatedJournal of Educational Computing Research, 1999
- Bioethics in the Laboratory: Synthesis & InteractivityThe American Biology Teacher, 1999
- Moral Education in the Zone of Proximal DevelopmentJournal of Moral Education, 1998
- A Method of Estimating Rater ReliabilityJournal of Educational Measurement, 1989