The Sound of Silence: Valuing Acoustics in Heritage Conservation
- 6 August 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Geographical Research
- Vol. 46 (3) , 361-373
Abstract
This paper explores the reasons behind the omission of historic acoustic values from heritage assessments in Australia. Best practice dictates that all cultural heritage values associated with significant places should be assessed in order to make informed conservation and management decisions. However, the multi‐sensory nature of aesthetics has been reframed in guidance documentation in ways that run counter to the primary frame. Conventions that have developed around the way places are assessed also work against comprehensive identification of values. As a result, the consideration of aesthetics in cultural heritage is limited to contemporary visual qualities. Furthermore, because the assessment of historic value takes a diachronic rather than synchronic approach, we have little knowledge of the places past communities valued for the sounds they experienced there. Research into landscape preference and acoustic ecology highlights the importance of identifying the inherent acoustic dimension of places and the role sound plays in developing a sense of place. Two landscape areas in Western Australia's south‐west with historic acoustic values, the Boranup Sand Patch and the Lower Reaches of the Blackwood River, illustrate how historic soundscapes can provide insightful contrasts and resonances with contemporary values, and how vulnerable such places are when the sound of place is overlooked in land management policies.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Victorian Soundscapes2003
- Sense Matters: aesthetic values of the Great Barrier ReefInternational Journal of Heritage Studies, 2002
- Heritage Conservation in Australia: A Frame in FluxJournal of Architectural Conservation, 2000
- Sound influence on landscape valuesLandscape and Urban Planning, 1999
- Toward a phenomenology of recreation placeJournal of Environmental Psychology, 1992
- Environmental PreferenceEnvironment and Behavior, 1989
- Danger, Mystery, and Environmental PreferenceEnvironment and Behavior, 1988
- A Cognitive Analysis of Preference for Natural Environments: Mountains, Canyons, and DesertsLandscape Journal, 1987
- Cultural and sub-cultural comparisons in preferences for natural settingsLandscape and Urban Planning, 1987
- Effects of Sounds on Preferences for Outdoor SettingsEnvironment and Behavior, 1983