Publishing in the Majors: A Comparison of Accounting, Finance, Management, and Marketing*
- 1 March 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 21 (1) , 223-255
Abstract
Business schools evaluate publication records, especially for the promotion and tenure decision, by comparing the quality and quantity of a candidate's research with those of peers within the same discipline (intradisciplinary) and with those of academics from other business disciplines (interdisciplinary). A recently developed analytical model of the research review process provides theory about the norms used by editors and referees in deciding whether to publish research papers. The model predicts that interdisciplinary differences exist in quality norms, which could result in disparity among business disciplines in the number of top‐tier articles published. I examine the period from 1980 to 1999 and, consistent with the theory, find that significant differences exist in the number of articles and proportion of doctoral faculty who published in the “major” journals in accounting, finance, management, and marketing. Most notably, the proportion of doctoral faculty publishing a major article is 1.4 to 2.4 times greater in the other business disciplines than in accounting (depending on the set of journals). The theory also predicts an upward drift over time in the quality norms used by referees. Consistent with a drift, the number of articles published has declined substantially in marketing and, to a lesser extent, in the other business disciplines.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploring Diversity in Accounting through Faculty Journal Perceptions*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2003
- Evolving Standards for Academic Publishing: A q‐r TheoryJournal of Political Economy, 2002
- The Slowdown of the Economics Publishing ProcessJournal of Political Economy, 2002
- On “Research vs. Teaching”: A Long-Term PerspectiveAccounting Horizons, 2000
- Report of the Editor for His Tenure and 1999*The Journal of Finance, 2000
- What Are the Research Standards for Full Professor of Finance?The Journal of Finance, 1998
- The Value of a Finance Journal PublicationThe Journal of Finance, 1998
- The Familiarity with and Perceived Quality of Accounting Journals: Views of Senior Accounting Faculty in Leading U.S. MBA Programs*Contemporary Accounting Research, 1994
- Across-discipline journal awareness and evaluation: Implications for the promotion and tenure processJournal of Economics and Business, 1990
- What Constitutes a Theoretical Contribution?Academy of Management Review, 1989