What Isn’t a Case-Control Study?
- 13 December 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Neurosurgery
- Vol. 84 (5) , 993-999
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Confusion exists among neurosurgeons when choosing and implementing an appropriate study design and statistical methods when conducting research. We noticed particular difficulty with mislabeled and inappropriate case-control studies in the neurosurgical literature. OBJECTIVE: To quantify and to rigorously review this issue for appropriateness in publication and to establish quality of the manuscripts using a rigorous technique. METHODS: Following a literature search, pairs drawn from 5 independent reviewers evaluated a complete sample of 125 manuscripts claiming to be case-control studies with respect to basic case-control criteria. Seventy-five papers were then subjected to a more rigorous appraisal for quality using the SIGN Methodology Checklist for case-control studies. RESULTS: Fifty publications were rejected based on basic criteria used to identify case-control design. Of the 75 subjected to quality analysis, 46 were felt to be acceptable for publication. Only 11 papers (9%) achieved the designation of high quality. Of the original 125 papers evaluated, 79 (63%) were inappropriately labeled case-control studies. CONCLUSION: Mislabeling and use of inappropriate study design are common in the neurosurgical literature. Manuscripts should be evaluated rigorously by reviewers and readers, and neurosurgical training programs should include instruction on choice of appropriate study design and critical appraisal of the literature.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Misclassification of Case-Control Studies in Neurosurgery and Proposed SolutionsWorld Neurosurgery, 2018
- Case-control studies in neurosurgeryJournal of Neurosurgery, 2014
- Maternal periconceptional factors affect the risk of spina bifida-affected pregnancies: an Italian case–control studyChild's Nervous System, 2011
- Case control study of periconceptional folic acid intake and nervous system tumors in childrenChild's Nervous System, 2010
- “Case-Control” ConfusionObstetrics & Gynecology, 2009
- Vascular risk factors and morphometric data in cervical artery dissection: a case-control studyJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 2009
- Risk Factors for Intracranial Hemorrhage among Full-term Infants: A Case-Control StudyNeurosurgery, 2003
- Psychiatric illness and subsequent traumatic brain injury: a case control studyJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 2002
- Prenatal vitamin supplementation and pediatric brain tumors: huge international variation in use and possible reduction in riskChild's Nervous System, 1998
- Risk factors for postoperative neurosurgical wound infectionJournal of Neurosurgery, 1986