Critical appraisal tools used in systematic reviews of in vitro cell culture studies: A methodological study
Authors:
- Victor Paiva BarbosaVBVictor Paiva Barbosa
- Bruna Bastos SilveiraBSBruna Bastos Silveira
- Juliana Amorim dos SantosJSJuliana Amorim dos Santos
- Mylene Martins MonteiroMMMylene Martins Monteiro
- Ricardo D. ColettaRicardo D. Coletta
- Graziela De Luca CantoGCGraziela De Luca Canto
- Cristine Miron StefaniCSCristine Miron Stefani
- Eliete Neves Silva GuerraEGEliete Neves Silva Guerra
- 18 July 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Research Synthesis Methods
- Vol. 14 (6) , 776-793
Abstract
Systematic reviews (SRs) of preclinical studies are marked with poor methodological quality. In vitro studies lack assessment tools to improve the quality of preclinical research. This methodological study aimed to identify, collect, and analyze SRs based on cell culture studies to highlight the current appraisal tools utilized to support the development of a validated critical appraisal tool for cell culture in vitro research. SRs, scoping reviews, and meta‐analyses that included cell culture studies and used any type of critical appraisal tool were included. Electronic search, study selection, data collection and methodological quality (MQ) assessment tool were realized. Further, statistical analyses regarding possible associations and correlations between MQ and collected data were performed. After the screening process, 82 studies remained for subsequent analysis. A total of 32 different appraisal tools were identified. Approximately 60% of studies adopted pre‐structured tools not designed for cell culture studies. The most frequent instruments were SYRCLE (n = 14), OHAT (n = 9), Cochrane Collaboration's tool (n = 7), GRADE (n = 6), CONSORT (n = 5), and ToxRTool (n = 5). The studies were divided into subgroups to perform statistical analyses. A significant association (OR = 5.00, 95% CI = 1.54–16.20, p = 0.008) was found between low MQ and chronic degenerative disorders as topic of SR. Several challenges in collecting information from the included studies led to some modifications related to the previously registered protocol. These results may serve as a basis for further development of a critical appraisal tool for cell culture studies capable of capturing all the essential factors related to preclinical research, therefore enhancing the practice of evidence‐based.Keywords
Funding Information
- Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico
This publication has 104 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis of Preclinical Studies: Why Perform Them and How to Appraise Them CriticallyJournal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism, 2014
- Evidence-based medicine: Revisiting the pyramid of prioritiesJournal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 2012
- The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trialsBMJ, 2011
- Mechanisms of Renal Cell Apoptosis Induced by Cyclosporine A: A Systematic Review of in vitro StudiesAmerican Journal of Nephrology, 2011
- GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction—GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tablesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2011
- “ToxRTool”, a new tool to assess the reliability of toxicological dataToxicology Letters, 2009
- Study Quality Assessment in Systematic Reviews of Research on Intervention EffectsResearch on Social Work Practice, 2008
- Pooling of Animal Experimental Data Reveals Influence of Study Design and Publication BiasStroke, 2004
- Improving the Reporting Quality of Nonrandomized Evaluations of Behavioral and Public Health Interventions: The TREND StatementAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2004
- Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in EpidemiologyA Proposal for ReportingJAMA, 2000