Dissolution of Continuity of Ethical Governance in Data Science Health Research: A Diagnostic and Response Framework for Lifecycle Oversight (Preprint)
Authors:
- Clement AdebamowoCAClement Adebamowo
- Sally N. AdebamowoSASally N. Adebamowo
- Adeola AkintolaAAAdeola Akintola
- Peter A. IkhanePIPeter A. Ikhane
- Simisola AkintolaSASimisola Akintola
- Temidayo O. OgundiranTOTemidayo O. Ogundiran
- Ayodele JegedeAJAyodele Jegede
- Olusegun AdeyemoOAOlusegun Adeyemo
- Shawneequa CallierSCShawneequa Callier
- Muhammad Imam-ThamimMIMuhammad Imam-Thamim
- Ibrahim UthmanIUIbrahim Uthman
Preprint
- 1 May 2026
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
UNSTRUCTURED Background: Traditional research ethics governance was built for bounded protocols, identifiable investigators, and temporally limited encounters with human participants. Data science health research (DSHR) disrupts that architecture because health data, biological materials, computational representations, and models persist, travel, combine, and acquire new uses across time. The ethical problem is not simply that individual instruments such as consent forms, IRB approvals, data access agreements, model cards, or privacy notices become outdated. It is that, across the lifecycle, the authorities that make these instruments ethically meaningful may lose jurisdiction, standing, evidentiary force, or remedial control. Conceptual contribution: This paper introduces Ethical Governance Continuity Dissolution (EGCD): the progressive and sometimes irreversible loss of domain-specific governance authority across a data, model, or biological-material lineage, such that no coherent assemblage of actors, instruments, rules, or community processes can any longer authorize, constrain, monitor, adjudicate, or remediate current use. EGCD differs from consent staleness, function creep, contextual integrity violations, algorithmic drift, and the continuity trap because it names the systemic condition in which several such failures become mutually reinforcing. Framework: Building on prior work on representational veracity and the continuity trap, we develop a six-domain authority taxonomy, diagnostic criteria, staging categories, and a prototype Ethical Continuity Dissolution Score. We then propose an Ethical Continuity Governance and Response Mechanism consisting of a continuity registry, continuity authority matrix, trigger-based lifecycle review, a Data Lifecycle Governance Officer, a Continuity Dissolution Review Board, cross-institutional audits, and community governance integration. Implications: EGCD provides a practical vocabulary and governance architecture for diagnosing and managing the loss of ethical governance continuity in global DSHR. The goal is not to freeze all original consent conditions indefinitely, but to prevent silent loss of governance authority as data, models, and biological materials move through increasingly complex research and translational ecosystems.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Medical Internet Research, 28, e99980.
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Community and bioethicists’ perspectives on iPSC research with biobanked samples collected using broad consentStem Cell Reports, 2025
- Patient consent for the secondary use of health data in artificial intelligence (AI) models: A scoping reviewInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2025
- Principles and methods for transferring polygenic risk scores across global populationsNature Reviews Genetics, 2023
- Global Biobank Meta-analysis Initiative: Powering genetic discovery across human diseaseCell Genomics, 2022
- A roadmap to increase diversity in genomic studiesNature Medicine, 2022
- Privacy in the age of medical big dataNature Medicine, 2019
- What allows a health care system to become a learning health care system: Results from interviews with health system leadersLearning Health Systems, 2016
- Dynamic consent: a patient interface for twenty-first century research networksEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2014
- An Ethics Framework for a Learning Health Care System: A Departure from Traditional Research Ethics and Clinical EthicsHastings Center Report, 2013
- What Makes Clinical Research Ethical?JAMA, 2000