Comparison of SCC-DFTB and NDDO-Based Semiempirical Molecular Orbital Methods for Organic Molecules
Authors:
- 23 November 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in The Journal of Physical Chemistry A
- Vol. 110 (50) , 13551-13559
Abstract
Extensive testing of the SCC−DFTB method has been performed, permitting direct comparison to data available for NDDO-based semiempirical methods. For 34 diverse isomerizations of neutral molecules containing the elements C, H, N, and O, the mean absolute errors (MAE) for the enthalpy changes are 2.7, 3.2, 5.0, 5.1, and 7.2 kcal/mol from PDDG/PM3, B3LYP/6-31G(d), PM3, SCC−DFTB, and AM1, respectively. A more comprehensive test was then performed by computing heats of formation for 622 neutral, closed-shell H, C, N, and O-containing molecules; the MAE of 5.8 kcal/mol for SCC−DFTB is intermediate between AM1 (6.8 kcal/mol) and PM3 (4.4 kcal/mol) and significantly higher than for PDDG/PM3 (3.2 kcal/mol). Similarly, SCC−DFTB is found to be less accurate for heats of formation of ions and radicals; however, it is more accurate for conformational energetics and intermolecular interaction energies, though none of the methods perform well for hydrogen bonds with strengths under ca. 7 kcal/mol. SCC−DFTB and the NDDO methods all reproduce MP2/cc-pVTZ molecular geometries with average errors for bond lengths, bond angles, and dihedral angles of only ca. 0.01 Å, 1.5°, and 3°. Testing was also carried out for sulfur containing molecules; SCC−DFTB currently yields much less accurate heats of formation in this case than the NDDO-based methods due to the over-stabilization of molecules containing an SO bond.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- RM1: A reparameterization of AM1 for H, C, N, O, P, S, F, Cl, Br, and IJournal of Computational Chemistry, 2006
- NO-MNDO: Reintroduction of the Overlap Matrix into MNDOJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 2006
- Extension of the PDDG/PM3 Semiempirical Molecular Orbital Method to Sulfur, Silicon, and PhosphorusJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 2005
- Extension of the PDDG/PM3 and PDDG/MNDO semiempirical molecular orbital methods to the halogensJournal of Computational Chemistry, 2003
- Computer Simulations of Enzyme Catalysis: Methods, Progress, and InsightsAnnual Review of Biophysics, 2003
- Combined Quantum Mechanical/Molecular Mechanical Methodologies Applied to Biomolecular SystemsAccounts of Chemical Research, 1999
- Calculations of molecules, clusters, and solids with a simplified LCAO-DFT-LDA schemeInternational Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 1996
- Construction of tight-binding-like potentials on the basis of density-functional theory: Application to carbonPhysical Review B, 1995
- Ground states of molecules. 39. MNDO results for molecules containing hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, and oxygenJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1977
- Effect of electronic state of carbon atoms on their reactions with cyclopentadiene in inert gas moderated systemsJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1977