The SORTEE Guidelines for Data and Code Quality Control in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology
Authors:
- Joel L PickJPJoel L Pick
- Bethany AllenBABethany Allen
- Erola FenollosaEFErola Fenollosa
- Esteban Fernández-JuricicEFEsteban Fernández-Juricic
Preprint
- 15 August 2025
- preprint
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Abstract
Open data and code are crucial to increasing transparency and reproducibility, and in building trust in scientific research. However, despite an increasing number of journals in ecology and evolutionary biology mandating for data and code to be archived alongside published articles, the amount and quality of archived data and code, and subsequent reproducibility of results, has remained worryingly low. As a result, a handful of journals have recruited dedicated data editors, whose role is to help authors increase the overall quality of archived data and code. There is, however, a general lack of consensus of what a data editor should check, how to do it, and to what level of detail, and the process is often vague and hidden from readers and authors alike. Here, with the input from multiple data editors across several journals in ecology and evolutionary biology, we establish and describe the first standardised guidelines for Data and Code Quality Control on behalf of the Society for Open, Reliable, and Transparent Ecology and Evolutionary Biology (SORTEE). We start by introducing the concept of a data editor and data and code quality control, what is expected from data and code quality control, the relative costs and benefits to journals, authors, and readers, and then introduce and detail the SORTEE-led guidelines, ending with advice for journals and authors. We believe that by adopting these standardised guidelines, journals will help increase the consistency and transparency of the data editor process for readers, authors, and data editors.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2025-08-25, HAL (Unconfirmed version)
- Published version: Peer Community Journal, 6.
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Functional R code is rare in species distribution and abundance papersEcology, 2024
- Code sharing in ecology and evolution increases citation rates but remains uncommonEcology and Evolution, 2024
- Reproducibility of COVID-era infectious disease modelsEpidemics, 2024
- Ensuring Prevention Science Research is Synthesis-Ready for Immediate and Lasting Scientific ImpactPrevention Science, 2021
- Why sharing data and code during peer review can enhance behavioral ecology researchBehavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 2021
- Doubling demands in programming skills call for ecoinformatics educationFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2020
- Evaluating the popularity of R in ecologyEcosphere, 2019
- Open science, reproducibility, and transparency in ecologyEcological Applications, 2018
- The mismatch between current statistical practice and doctoral training in ecologyEcosphere, 2016
- Public sharing of research datasets: A pilot study of associationsJournal of Informetrics, 2010