Why the quantum
Authors:
- W. M. StuckeyWSW. M. Stuckey
- Michael SilbersteinMSMichael Silberstein
- Timothy McDevittTMTimothy McDevitt
- Ian KohlerIKIan Kohler
Preprint
Abstract
To answer Wheeler's question "Why the quantum?" via quantum information theory according to Bub, one must explain both why the world is quantum rather than classical and why the world is quantum rather than superquantum, i.e., "Why the Tsirelson bound?" We show that the quantum correlations resulting from spin one-half states, i.e., the spin singlet state and 'Mermin photon state', which uniquely produce the Tsirelson bound for the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) quantity, can be derived from the conservation of angular momentum (on average) for the quantum exchange of momentum. This explanation of the Tsirelson bound does not require hidden variables or 'causal influences', local or nonlocal. Since superquantum correlations exceed quantum correlations, we know that they would also violate conservation of angular momentum and we show how this happens using the Popescu-Rohrlich (PR) correlations. Thus, quantum correlations responsible for the Tsirelson bound satisfy conservation of angular momentum for the quantum exchange of momentum while both classical and superquantum correlations can fail to satisfy this constraint. We generalize the result to conservation per any measurement associated with a Bell basis state. While this constraint is not surprising per se, the details on how it obtains evidence a deeper principle at work in Nature, i.e., no preferred reference frame.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Making Sense of Bell’s Theorem and Quantum NonlocalityFoundations of Physics, 2017
- Approaching Tsirelson’s Bound in a Photon Pair ExperimentPhysical Review Letters, 2015
- Arbitrary violation of the Tsirelson boundPhysical Review A, 2012
- Information causality as a physical principleNature, 2009
- Causality and Tsirelson's boundsPhysical Review A, 2005
- Quantum/classical correspondence in the light of Bell's inequalitiesFoundations of Physics, 1992
- A sum-over-histories account of an EPR(B) experimentFoundations of Physics Letters, 1991
- On the violation of Bell's inequality in quantum theoryPhysics Letters A, 1987
- Bell Inequalities with a Range of Violation that Does Not Diminish as the Spin Becomes Arbitrarily LargePhysical Review Letters, 1982
- Proposed Experiment to Test Local Hidden-Variable TheoriesPhysical Review Letters, 1969