Disagreements as a form of knowledge: How journalists address day-to-day conflicts between sources
- 31 January 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 22 (4) , 882-900
Abstract
Disagreements over facts, in which news sources are leading journalists in opposite directions, are an ultimate test of journalists’ knowledge, forcing them to develop their own understanding of the actual state of affairs. This study focuses on how reporters think, act, and establish knowledge during the coverage of day-to-day disagreements – contrary to former studies, which focused on large-scale scientific and political controversies based on content analysis that narrowed their exposure to the epistemic realities of disagreements. Using a combination of quantitative and qualitative reconstruction interviews we show that rather than eliciting an ‘epistemic paralysis’, as widely expected in the literature, disagreements attract significantly greater knowledge-acquisition energy. Findings support the problem-centered approach of epistemology and pragmatics that highlight the complexities of disagreements, rather than the adjudication-centered approach of journalism studies, which push for more journalistic ‘bottom lines’. Maximizing adjudication seems too ambitious and unrealistic for the time frame of daily reporting and the mixed epistemic standards seen in this study.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sources in the NewsJournalism Studies, 2013
- Debunking Sarah Palin: Mainstream news coverage of ‘death panels’Journalism, 2011
- Effects of Unresolved Factual Disputes in the News on Epistemic Political EfficacyJournal of Communication, 2011
- Multiperspectival news revisited: Journalism and representative democracyJournalism, 2011
- A Question of BalanceScience Communication, 2008
- On Pragmatic Encroachment in EpistemologyPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 2007
- Conflict Framing Categories RevisitedCommunication Quarterly, 2006
- Framing European politics: A Content Analysis of Press and Television NewsJournal of Communication, 2000
- On the Relevance of Standpoint Epistemology to the Practice of Journalism: The Case for "Strong Objectivity"Communication Theory, 1998
- Sampling for qualitative researchFamily Practice, 1996