Do inconclusive forensic decisions disadvantage the innocent?
- 1 February 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Law and Human Behavior
- Vol. 48 (1) , 33-49
Abstract
Objective: Two experiments examined the potential for inconclusive forensic decisions to disadvantage the innocent. Hypotheses: Both experiments tested the hypothesis that inconclusive decisions produce more incriminating legal judgments than do clearly exculpatory forensic decisions. Experiment 2 also examined whether this hypothesized effect conformed to a confirmation bias, a communication error, or perceptual accuracy. Method: In Experiment 1 (N = 492), a forensic expert testified that physical evidence recovered from a crime scene either matched or did not match a suspect's evidence or produced an inconclusive result. In Experiment 2 (N = 1,002), a forensic expert testified that physical evidence recovered from a crime scene either matched or did not match a suspect's evidence, produced an inconclusive result, or was unsuitable for analysis. A fifth condition omitted the forensic evidence and expert testimony. Results: The inconclusive decision produced less incriminating legal judgments than did the match forensic decision (|d|average = 0.96), more incriminating legal judgments than did the no-match forensic decision (|d|average = 0.62), and equivalent legal judgments to the unsuitable decision (|d|average = 0.12) and to legal judgments made in the absence of forensic evidence (|d|average = 0.07). These results suggest that participants interpreted the inconclusive decision to be forensically neutral, which is consistent with a communication error. Conclusion: The findings provide preliminary support for the idea that inconclusive decisions can put the innocent at risk of wrongful conviction by depriving them of a clearly exculpatory forensic decision.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- A study of examiner accuracy in cartridge case comparisons. Part 2: Examiner use of the AFTE range of conclusionsForensic Science International, 2023
- Accuracy, reproducibility, and repeatability of forensic footwear examiner decisionsForensic Science International, 2022
- Forensic science and the principle of excluded middle: “Inconclusive” decisions and the structure of error rate studiesForensic Science International: Synergy, 2021
- Testing the accuracy and reliability of palmar friction ridge comparisons – A black box studyForensic Science International, 2021
- Commentary on: I. Dror, N Scurich “(Mis)use of scientific measurements in forensic science” Forensic Science International: Synergy 2020 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fsisyn.2020.08.006Forensic Science International: Synergy, 2020
- NIST interlaboratory studies involving DNA mixtures (MIX05 and MIX13): Variation observed and lessons learnedForensic Science International: Genetics, 2018
- Précis of Social Perception and Social Reality: Why accuracy dominates bias and self-fulfilling prophecyBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 2015
- Subjectivity and bias in forensic DNA mixture interpretationScience & Justice, 2011
- Jury decision making research: Are researchers focusing on the mouse and not the elephant in the room?Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 2011
- Information Gain of Psychophysiological Detection of Deception in Forensic and Screening SettingsApplied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback, 2009