Unresolved Tensions in Sociocultural Theory: Analogies with Contemporary Sociological Debates
Author:
- 1 September 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Culture & Psychology
- Vol. 8 (3) , 283-305
Abstract
Socioculturalists are divided on two of the foundational theoretical claims of the paradigm: a process ontologyof the social world; and the inseparabilityof the individual and the group. A process ontology holds that only processes are real; entities, structures or patterns are ephemeral and do not really exist. Inseparability is the claim that the individual and the social cannot be methodologically or ontologically distinguished. To clarify the different stances toward these claims held by socioculturalists, I draw on the contemporary sociological debate between Anthony Giddens and Margaret Archer. Giddens’ structuration theory holds to a process ontology and to inseparability, while Archer’s emergentist theory rejects both. I borrow the terms of this debate to clarify the tensions among several prominent socioculturalists, including Cole, Lave and Wenger, Rogoff, Shweder, Valsiner, and Wertsch. I argue that a strong form of inseparability is theoretically problematic and empirically untenable, and I conclude that socioculturalists can resolve these tensions by adopting an ‘analytic dualism’ that retains key sociocultural commitments.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dualisms Displaced:From Crusades to Analytic DistinctionsHuman Development, 1998
- When Solo Activity Is Not Privileged: Participation and Internalization Models of DevelopmentHuman Development, 1998
- The supra-individual envelope of development activity and practice, situation and contextNew Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 1995
- The Confessions of a Methodological IndividualistCulture & Psychology, 1995
- Conceptual Roots of Internalization: From Transmission to TransformationHuman Development, 1993
- CommentaryHuman Development, 1993
- Three Ways to Relate Person and Culture: Thoughts Sparked by Valsiner’s Review ofApprenticeship in ThinkingHuman Development, 1992
- Building Theoretical Bridges over a Lagoon of Everyday EventsHuman Development, 1991
- Constructing Social Theory and Constituting SocietyTheory, Culture & Society, 1986
- Displacement of Scope: A Problem of the Relationship Between Small-Scale and Large-Scale Sociological TheoriesAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1964