This study analyzes the development of Critical Thinking (CT) in Science Education (SE) in the Early Years (EY) of Elementary School, highlighting its relevance in the face of technological and social transformations, as CT is essential for forming autonomous, reflective, and socially engaged citizens. This qualitative and bibliographic research identified and analyzed 16 Brazilian dissertations and theses, and conducted interviews with 7 female teachers—professionals in education and in the field of Natural Sciences—who participated in a formative discussion circle. The results, analyzed through Bardin’s (2016) content analysis methodology, revealed that although CT is still underexplored in the national context, there is growing appreciation for investigative pedagogical strategies with the potential to foster CT in SE. The main conceptions of CT observed were critical reflection aimed at social emancipation, scientific culture, and rational-reflective thinking. Thus, the development of CT in SE requires initial and continuing teacher education, articulated with strategies that stimulate students’ critical awareness from an early age, in favor of a society minimally scientifically literate.