Surgical Fixation Versus Cast Immobilization for Adults With Bicortical Scaphoid Fractures: A Target Trial Emulation of the SWIFFT Trial
Open Access
- 2 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
- Vol. 34 (15) , e2173-e2185
Abstract
Aims: The Scaphoid Waist Internal Fixation for Fractures Trial (SWIFFT) reported no notable difference in functional outcomes between surgical fixation and cast immobilization for minimally displaced scaphoid waist fractures in UK settings. We aimed to emulate SWIFFT using Chinese hospital electronic health record (EHR) data to evaluate whether similar treatment effects are observed in a population with different risk profiles and to identify subgroups that may benefit differentially from surgery. Methods: This target trial emulation used a clone-censor-weight design with inverse probability of treatment and censoring weighting. Deidentified EHR data were extracted from three Tertiary A teaching hospitals in China (July 2018 to August 2024). Adults aged 16 years or older with a bicortical scaphoid waist fracture (displacement ≤2 mm) presenting within 14 days of injury were eligible. Patients received either headless compression screw fixation (n = 2,544) or below-elbow cast immobilization (n = 4,225). The primary outcome was the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score at 52 weeks. Results: Among 6,769 patients (mean age 32.1 years; 81.6% male; 42.4% current smokers), surgery produced statistically significant DASH improvements at all time points. At 52 weeks, the adjusted mean difference was −4.2 (95% CI, −4.9 to −3.5; P < 0.001), below commonly cited MCID estimates (10 to 15 points) but approaching lower proposed thresholds (7 to 10 points). Surgery halved nonunion risk (8.4% vs 17.5%; RR 0.48, 95% CI, 0.41 to 0.55) but increased complications sevenfold (14.1% vs 2.0%), predominantly screw-related. Subgroup analyses showed larger surgical benefits among patients with displaced fractures (−8.5) and current smokers (−6.7). Nearly one in five cast-treated patients (18.1%) ultimately required surgery for nonunion. Conclusion: Surgery was associated with statistically significant but modest DASH improvements, halved nonunion risk, and a sevenfold increase in complications. Cast immobilization remains a reasonable initial strategy for undisplaced fractures, while surgery offers measurable advantages for displaced fractures or smokers.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Transparent Reporting of Observational Studies Emulating a Target Trial—The TARGET StatementJAMA, 2025
- Cast selection and non-union rates for acute scaphoid fractures treated conservatively: a systematic review and meta-analysisJournal of Plastic Surgery and Hand Surgery, 2022
- Surgery versus cast immobilisation for adults with a bicortical fracture of the scaphoid waist (SWIFFT): a pragmatic, multicentre, open-label, randomised superiority trialThe Lancet, 2020
- An Epidemiologic Perspective on Scaphoid Fracture Treatment and Frequency of Nonunion Surgery in the USAHSS Journal®: The Musculoskeletal Journal of Hospital for Special Surgery, 2018
- Using Big Data to Emulate a Target Trial When a Randomized Trial Is Not Available: Table 1.American Journal of Epidemiology, 2016
- Scaphoid fracture epidemiology2012
- Surgical Versus Nonsurgical Treatment of Acute Minimally Displaced and Undisplaced Scaphoid Waist Fractures: Pairwise and Network Meta-Analyses of Randomized Controlled TrialsThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2011
- An Introduction to Propensity Score Methods for Reducing the Effects of Confounding in Observational StudiesMultivariate Behavioral Research, 2011
- Coding Algorithms for Defining Comorbidities in ICD-9-CM and ICD-10 Administrative DataMedical Care, 2005
- EPIDEMIOLOGY OF SCAPHOID FRACTURES IN BERGEN, NORWAYScandinavian Journal of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery and Hand Surgery, 1999