The (Non-)equivalence of dividends and share buybacks
Open Access
- 28 July 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Mathematics and Financial Economics
- Vol. 19 (4) , 807-849
Abstract
We study a one-period equilibrium model in which a firm optimally determines its equity distribution level to maximize the expected utility of a representative shareholder. Dividends and share buybacks, the two most prevalent payout methods, are compared and contrasted. In our baseline setup, we demonstrate a Modigliani-Miller-style equivalence, where both dividend payouts and share buybacks result in the same shareholder welfare, distribution ratio and firm’s investment level. However, share buybacks lead to a higher firm price in equilibrium. This conclusion is robust to alternative modeling specifications, such as heterogeneous beliefs among investors and endogenous riskfree rates. We also provide examples where this equivalence breaks down due to distortions in managerial incentives or market frictions. For example, firm managers endowed with employee stock options strictly prefer buybacks over dividends. In the presence of trading constraints, the relative attractiveness of dividends versus buybacks becomes ambiguous.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Equilibrium CEO contract with belief heterogeneityEconomic Theory, 2022
- CEO option incentives and corporate share repurchasesInternational Review of Economics & Finance, 2022
- Disappearing and reappearing dividendsJournal of Financial Economics, 2022
- Shareholder heterogeneity, asymmetric information, and the equilibrium managerEconomic Theory, 2021
- Share repurchases, catering, and dividend substitutionJournal of Corporate Finance, 2013
- The evolving relation between earnings, dividends, and stock repurchasesJournal of Financial Economics, 2008
- Stock repurchases as an earnings management deviceJournal of Accounting and Economics, 2006
- R2 around the world: New theory and new tests☆Journal of Financial Economics, 2006
- Explaining investor preference for cash dividendsJournal of Financial Economics, 1984
- Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structureJournal of Financial Economics, 1976