Effectiveness of legally mandated non-custodial drug and alcohol treatment orders for improved health, well-being, global functioning and quality of life: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Authors:
- Pauline CampbellPCPauline Campbell
- Julie CowieJCJulie Cowie
- Bridget DavisBDBridget Davis
- Candida FentonCFCandida Fenton
- Alex Todhunter-BrownATAlex Todhunter-Brown
- Louise HoyleLHLouise Hoyle
- Hannah CarverHCHannah Carver
- Catriona ConnellCCCatriona Connell
- Joshua DumbrellJDJoshua Dumbrell
- Rosie HillRHRosie Hill
Open Access
- 27 January 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health & Justice
- Vol. 14 (1)
Abstract
Background: Adults in the criminal justice system are disproportionately more likely to use alcohol and drugs compared to the general population. Legally mandated alcohol and drug treatment orders have been proposed as an alternative to prison. However, little is known about how treatment orders affect the health and well-being of this population. Methods: A systematic review and meta-analysis. We searched 14 electronic databases (last searched November 2023) for studies comparing adults in legally mandated non-custodial drug and alcohol treatment orders to those receiving mandatory treatment orders or usual care. Global functioning, quality of life, drug or alcohol use measures, dependence severity, depression/anxiety outcomes, family member/significant other outcomes, and adverse events were selected based on a minimum core outcome set. We performed a meta-analysis using mean differences and risk ratios with 95% confidence intervals. We assessed the certainty of the evidence using GRADE. Equity-related factors were mapped to the PROGRESS-plus framework. People with lived experience provided input throughout the review process. Results: From 6917 records, 11 studies involving 4643 individuals (70% men; seven randomised controlled trials (RCTs)) met the eligibility criteria. All studies were conducted in high-income countries and involved drug and alcohol courts. The main outcomes of global functioning and quality of life were not reported. Poor reporting limited the meta-analysis. There were no differences between the groups receiving the intervention and those in the control group regarding number of positive drug screenings (MD -0.80, 95% CI -3.60 to 2.00, 10 participants, p = 0.58); depression (RR 0.93, 95% CI 0.78 to 1.10, 1533 participants, p = 0.38); or serious adverse events (RR 0.33, 95% CI 0.02 to 6.65, 10 participants, p = 0.47). We judged the evidence as very-low. The equity criteria most frequently reported were age, sex and race/ethnicity. Conclusions: The evidence is insufficient to draw judgements about the effectiveness of treatment orders for health and well-being. We found no evidence relating to global functioning, quality of life, anxiety, and outcomes specific to family members or significant others. High-quality RCTs are urgently needed. Future studies should involve people with lived experience in the design and conduct of new trials. Study protocol registration. The protocol for this study was registered on PROSPERO: CRD42023484923.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- The price of retribution: evidence from the willingness to pay for short-term prison sentences compared to community service ordersJournal of Experimental Criminology, 2023
- Assessing the effectiveness of problem-solving courts on the reduction of overdose deaths in the United States: A difference-in-difference studyDrug and Alcohol Dependence Reports, 2022
- Citationchaser: A tool for transparent and efficient forward and backward citation chasing in systematic searchingResearch Synthesis Methods, 2022
- A systematic review of qualitative evidence on barriers to and facilitators of the implementation of opioid agonist treatment (OAT) programmes in prisonsInternational Journal of Drug Policy, 2021
- Risk‐of‐bias VISualization (robvis): An R package and Shiny web app for visualizing risk‐of‐bias assessmentsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2020
- Examining the efficacy of a computer facilitated HIV prevention tool in drug courtDrug and Alcohol Dependence, 2016
- The effectiveness of compulsory drug treatment: A systematic reviewInternational Journal of Drug Policy, 2016
- Predicting Criminal Recidivism Following Drug Court: Implications for Drug Court Practice and Policy AdvocacyJournal of Addictions & Offender Counseling, 2014
- GRADE guidelines: 4. Rating the quality of evidence—study limitations (risk of bias)Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2011
- Long-term effects of participation in the Baltimore City drug treatment court: Results from an experimental studyJournal of Experimental Criminology, 2006