Was There Really a Social Efficiency Doctrine? The Uses and Abuses of an Idea in Educational History
Authors:
- 1 April 2013
- journal article
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA) in Educational Researcher
- Vol. 42 (3) , 142-150
Abstract
In the historiography on curriculum reform during the progressive era, one interpretive lens has dominated the study of 20th-century reform for more than 40 years: the idea of the social efficiency doctrine. In this historiographical essay, the authors briefly trace the rise of social efficiency as an idea in curriculum history, identify the four common assertions on which it is based, review the recent studies that challenge these assertions, and finally, suggest some ways to rescue the term from overuse and abuse. The authors argue that, historically speaking, social efficiency was a widely used, poorly defined, highly problematic term that had multiple uses for multiple scholars between the 1890s and the 1930s. Historiographically speaking, the authors argue the idea of the social efficiency doctrine has been an inconsistent, heterogeneous, and imprecise lens through which to explain long-term curriculum change.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- G. Stanley Hall and an American Social Darwinist Pedagogy: His Progressive Educational Ideas on Gender and RaceHistory of Education Quarterly, 2012
- Teaching under the new Taylorism: high‐stakes testing and the standardization of the 21 st century curriculumJournal of Curriculum Studies, 2011
- John Dewey’s Influence on the Origins of the Social Studies: An Analysis of the Historiography and New InterpretationReview of Educational Research, 2009
- From Kidd to Dewey: the origin and meaning of ‘social efficiency’Journal of Curriculum Studies, 2009
- Curriculum History and Its Revisionist Legacy2008
- Progressive Pioneer: Alexander James Inglis (1879–1924) and American Secondary EducationTeachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education, 2006
- W. E. B. Du Bois, German Social Thought, and the Racial Divide in American Progressivism, 1892-1909Journal of American History, 2001
- A Progressive Legacy Squandered: TheCardinal PrinciplesReport ReconsideredHistory of Education Quarterly, 2001
- Origins of the Modern Social Studies: 1900-1916History of Education Quarterly, 1983
- In Search of ProgressivismReviews in American History, 1982