Creating law of interpretation: a risky or fundamental step?
Author:
- Paulina KoncaPKPaulina Konca
Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by OpenEdition in Revus
- Vol. 45
Abstract
In some countries there is no legislation regulating legal interpretation, but in others, various interpretive tools and guidelines are regulated by the legislature. The regulation of interpretation is primarily considered an opportunity to increase legal certainty. Some authors note, however, that statutory regulation of legal interpretation involves certain risks, such as the danger of violating the principle of separation of powers. Questions also arise as to whether the legislator has the right to bind future legislators, whether the law of interpretation can have retroactive effect, and how to interpret the interpretative provisions. This paper addresses these challenges. In discussing this matter, it refers to the regulations of four countries: Australia, Spain, Ireland, and Poland. Each of them serves as an example of adopting different solutions to the problem of interpretation regulation. The main argument is that the legislature can regulate interpretation, either through direct or indirect legislative intervention. To a large extent, law of interpretation can enhance uniformity in a preventive manner and restore disturbed certainty by providing mechanisms to resolve serious discrepancies in judicial practice. It can also serve as a safeguard for other principles and values.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Authentic InterpretationRatio Juris, 2020
- Materiały legislacyjne w świetle prawa, praktyki orzeczniczej i poglądów doktryny z perspektywy polskiej i hiszpańskiejArchiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, 2019
- Judging Ordinary MeaningSSRN Electronic Journal, 2017
- Interpreting Statutes2016
- What questions of interpretation may be raised by the new Hungarian constitution?ICL Journal, 2012
- The Impossibility of Textualism and the Pervasiveness of Rewriting in LawCanadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence, 2009
- Restatement (First) of Statutory InterpretationSSRN Electronic Journal, 2003
- Federal Rules of Statutory InterpretationHarvard Law Review, 2002
- Mother May I? Imposing Mandatory Prospective Rules of Statutory InterpretationSSRN Electronic Journal, 2002
- A Plea for a Law of InterpretationUniversity of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1950