DIMENSIONS OF KNOWLEDGE IN PROTOTYPING: A REVIEW AND CHARACTERISATION OF PROTOTYPING METHODS AND THEIR CONTRIBUTIONS TO DESIGN KNOWLEDGE
Open Access
- 27 July 2021
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Proceedings of the Design Society
- Vol. 1, 1303-1312
Abstract
Whilst prior works have characterised the affordances of prototyping methods in terms of generating knowledge about a product or process, the types, or ‘dimensions’ of knowledge towards which they contribute are not fully understood. In this paper we adapt the concept of ‘design domains’ as a method to interpret, and better understand the contributions of different prototyping methods to design knowledge in new product development. We first synthesise a set of ten dimensions for design knowledge from a review of literature in design-related fields. A study was then conducted in which participants from engineering backgrounds completed a Likert-type questionnaire to quantify the perceived contributions to design knowledge of 90 common prototyping methods against each dimension. We statistically analyse results to identify patterns in the knowledge contribution of different methods. Results reveal that methods exhibit significantly different contribution profiles, suggesting different methods to be suited to different knowledge. Thus, this paper indicates potential for new methods, methodology and processes to leverage such characterisations for better selection and sequencing of methods in the prototyping process.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Accelerating product prototyping through hybrid methods: Coupling 3D printing and LEGODesign Studies, 2019
- Design prototyping methods: state of the art in strategies, techniques, and guidelinesDesign Science, 2017
- Collaborative Prototyping: Cross‐Fertilization of Knowledge in Prototype‐Driven Problem SolvingJournal of Product Innovation Management, 2013
- The Form of Practical Knowledge2009
- Experience prototyping2000
- What do Prototypes Prototype?1997
- Evaluating prototyping technologies for product designResearch in Engineering Design, 1992
- Kinds of seeing and their functions in designingDesign Studies, 1992