The Workfare Illusion: Re‐examining the Concept and the British Case
- 19 November 2007
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Social Policy & Administration
- Vol. 42 (1) , 19-42
Abstract
This article contends that workfare programmes pursued by various OECD countries since the mid‐1990s do not amount to a fundamental change in policy. The limited potential of workfare is due to the fact that it fails to transcend the constraints of earlier forms of ‘active’ responses to unemployment. Furthermore, it suffers from specific policy‐making disadvantages not shared by these responses. The article opens with a survey of relevant academic debates on the subject. It then places workfare in a broader context by identifying its functional reach, as compared to other active policy responses to unemployment such as active labour market policy (ALMP). The third section analyses workfare policies in the United Kingdom, as developed since 1997, by re‐examining the British New Deal employment programme. That review demonstrates that workfare policies either depend on their ‘fit’ with the existing policy‐making heritage, or that they remain merely symbolic. The article concludes by suggesting that the potential of workfare to effect change in responses to unemployment continues to be of limited significance. In other words, capitalist employment and welfare systems continue to be characterized by incremental adaptation rather than by fundamental regime change as suggested by the critics of workfare.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- What's Wrong with Workfare?Journal of Applied Philosophy, 2004
- Importing Workfare: Policy Transfer of Social and Labour Market Policies from the USA to Britain under New LabourSocial Policy & Administration, 2004
- ‘New Labour’, welfare reform and the reserve army of labourCapital & Class, 2003
- Incapacity Benefit and unemployment2003
- Welfare Reform in WisconsinAdministration & Society, 2001
- Public employment programs, workfare, and welfare reformReview of Radical Political Economics, 2001
- Welfare reform for low income workersOxford Economic Papers, 2001
- Modernizing Social Security? Labour and its Welfare‐to‐work StrategySocial Policy & Administration, 2000
- Commentary. 'Work first': workfare and the regulation of contingent labour marketsCambridge Journal of Economics, 2000
- The Father of the Swedish Model in Memory of Gosta Rehn (1913-96)Economic and Industrial Democracy, 1997