An Extensive Study on Cross-Dataset Bias and Evaluation Metrics Interpretation for Machine Learning applied to Gastrointestinal Tract Abnormality Classification
Preprint
Abstract
Precise and efficient automated identification of Gastrointestinal (GI) tract diseases can help doctors treat more patients and improve the rate of disease detection and identification. Currently, automatic analysis of diseases in the GI tract is a hot topic in both computer science and medical-related journals. Nevertheless, the evaluation of such an automatic analysis is often incomplete or simply wrong. Algorithms are often only tested on small and biased datasets, and cross-dataset evaluations are rarely performed. A clear understanding of evaluation metrics and machine learning models with cross datasets is crucial to bring research in the field to a new quality level. Towards this goal, we present comprehensive evaluations of five distinct machine learning models using Global Features and Deep Neural Networks that can classify 16 different key types of GI tract conditions, including pathological findings, anatomical landmarks, polyp removal conditions, and normal findings from images captured by common GI tract examination instruments. In our evaluation, we introduce performance hexagons using six performance metrics such as recall, precision, specificity, accuracy, F1-score, and Matthews Correlation Coefficient to demonstrate how to determine the real capabilities of models rather than evaluating them shallowly. Furthermore, we perform cross-dataset evaluations using different datasets for training and testing. With these cross-dataset evaluations, we demonstrate the challenge of actually building a generalizable model that could be used across different hospitals. Our experiments clearly show that more sophisticated performance metrics and evaluation methods need to be applied to get reliable models rather than depending on evaluations of the splits of the same dataset, i.e., the performance metrics should always be interpreted together rather than relying on a single metric.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Detecting colorectal polyps via machine learningNature Biomedical Engineering, 2018
- Automatic Polyp Detection via a Novel Unified Bottom-Up and Top-Down Saliency ApproachIEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics, 2017
- Efficient disease detection in gastrointestinal videos – global features versus neural networksMultimedia Tools and Applications, 2017
- Polyp-Alert: Near real-time feedback during colonoscopyComputer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 2015
- WM-DOVA maps for accurate polyp highlighting in colonoscopy: Validation vs. saliency maps from physiciansComputerized Medical Imaging and Graphics, 2015
- Part-Based Multiderivative Edge Cross-Sectional Profiles for Polyp Detection in ColonoscopyIEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics, 2014
- Towards automatic polyp detection with a polyp appearance modelPattern Recognition, 2012
- Quality and colonoscopy: a new imperativeGastrointestinal Endoscopy, 2005
- A Tutorial on the Cross-Entropy MethodAnnals of Operations Research, 2005
- Logistic Model TreesLecture Notes in Computer Science, 2003