Abuse of a corpse: A brief history and re-theorization of necrophilia laws in the USA
Author:
- 16 May 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Mortality
- Vol. 13 (2) , 132-152
Abstract
In September 2006, Wisconsin police discovered Nicholas Grunke, Alexander Grunke, and Dustin Radtke digging into the grave of a recently deceased woman. Upon questioning by police, Alexander Grunke explained that the three men wanted to exhume the body for sexual intercourse. In the Wisconsin state court system, the three men were charged with attempted third-degree sexual assault and attempted theft. None of the men could be charged with attempted necrophilia, since the state of Wisconsin has no law making necrophilia illegal. What the Wisconsin case exposed was the following gap in US jurisprudence: many states have no law prohibiting necrophilia. This article on US necrophilia laws argues that human corpses and the laws that govern the use of dead bodies are uniquely positioned to cause precisely these legal discrepancies since the dead body is a quasi-subject before the law. This examination also presents an argument about one of the fundamental reasons that this gap in US law exists. Specifically, it is argued that the ambiguous juridical standing of the human corpse in necrophilia cases compounds the sexual monstrousness of the necrophiliac and of necrophilic acts. This article is the first part of a much larger study on the dead body and the law.Keywords
This publication has 3 references indexed in Scilit:
- Flat American Waltzthe minnesota review, 2006
- An extreme case of necrophiliaLegal Medicine, 2000
- Necrophilia, brief review and case reportPsychiatric Quarterly, 1958