When (and When Not) to Make Exceptions: Links among Age, Precedent Setting Decisions, and Argument Evaluation
- 5 June 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Genetic Psychology
- Vol. 180 (4-5) , 170-184
Abstract
Negative precedents are set when, in the absence of mitigating conditions, social rules are not enforced by relevant authorities. This study examined the effects of normative (i.e., to enforce rules) and nonnormative arguments (i.e., to “make exceptions”) on decisions that could establish negative precedents and whether those effects differed for children and adolescents. As expected, on baseline problems, age correlated positively with decision-making performance. After receiving normative arguments, normative decisions increased and adolescents—but not preadolescents—transferred their understanding to novel problems. Nonnormative arguments led to decrements in normative decisions across ages. However, only for preadolescents did performance decrements following nonnormative arguments transfer to novel problems. Discussion focuses on the abilities to engage in “metacognitive intercession,” variability in children’s and adolescents’ decisions, and developments in the understanding of the consequences of violating the social rules.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Is It Really Robust?Methodology, 2010
- When can we say ‘if’?Cognition, 2008
- Current theories of risk and rational decision makingDevelopmental Review, 2008
- A social neuroscience perspective on adolescent risk-takingDevelopmental Review, 2008
- Age differences in resistance to peer influence.Developmental Psychology, 2007
- On the resolution of conflict in dual process theories of reasoningThinking & Reasoning, 2007
- Individual differences in reasoning: Implications for the rationality debate?Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2000
- Conditional reasoning with inducements and adviceCognition, 1998
- Children's Conceptions of Fair Government and Freedom of SpeechChild Development, 1998
- Risk taking in adolescence: A decision-making perspectiveDevelopmental Review, 1992