Divine subjectivity and intersubjectivity
Open Access
- 12 April 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Religious Studies
- Vol. 60 (3) , 390-402
Abstract
This article expands my previous work on omnisubjectivity, the divine property of having a complete and perfect grasp of the subjective states of all beings who have such states. By a subjective state I mean a conscious state as that state is experienced by the one who has it. I argue that only a being with subjectivity can be omnisubjective, and therefore, God has subjective states. The article explores the subjectivity of God as it applies to the Christian doctrines of the Trinity and the Incarnation, focusing on the important difference between a person and an instance of a nature. I propose that the uniqueness of persons is grounded in their unique subjective states, not their objective nature. Each person of the Trinity has a unique point of view and unique subjectivity even though they share an objective divine nature instantiated in a single divine being. The Son has a single set of subjective states before, during, and after the Incarnation. Each member of the Trinity is omnisubjective and fully grasps the unique subjective states of each other person of the Trinity. The perfect comprehension of each other while remaining unique persons is a model of perfect love within a community of persons.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Union and IndwellingNova et vetera, 2019
- The Hypostatic Union: Personhood, Consciousness, and KnowledgeNova et vetera, 2019
- The social theory of the TrinityReligious Studies, 2018
- Omnisubjectivity and IncarnationTopoi, 2016
- Response to Linda Zagzebski’s “Omnisubjectivity: Why It Is a Divine Attribute”Nova et vetera, 2016
- Omnisubjectivity: Why It Is a Divine AttributeNova et vetera, 2016
- Omniscience, the Incarnation, and Knowledge de seEuropean Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 2012
- What Does Chalcedon Solve and What Does It Not? Some Reflections on the Status and Meaning of the Chalcedonian ‘Definition’2002
- The Uniqueness of PersonsJournal of Religious Ethics, 2001
- Omniscience and experienceInternational Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 1991