Resilience and the politics of multiplicity
Authors:
Open Access
- 16 March 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Dialogues in Human Geography
- Vol. 6 (1) , 45-49
Abstract
In this response to the commentaries, we expand on the intent behind the format of our article, which was undertaken in order to understand how resilience might be politically taken to task in light of the divergent ways in which it appears in the world. We take on (and sympathize with) the critique that our article sacrifices the ethnographic depth central to Mol’s work on ontological politics, which forms the conceptual backbone of our arguments. Although this approach could not dig deep into each instance, we argue that it did allow common currents of resilience politics to come to the fore, namely, questions concerning ontologies of site and intervention that should be asked of all resilience enactments. From here, we engage with the different commentaries related to politics and critical thought and insist on our core concern that ontologies of site and intervention are crucial for interrogating security, care, and responsibility, which are fundamentally at stake in all resilience governance. Finally, we reflect on ways in which our article was perhaps not multiple enough and draw encouragement from the commentaries that applied our questions of site and intervention to the authors’ own situated perspectives or areas of study, in particular through indigenous ontologies. These are taken as illustrations of the value of attending to the ontological politics of resilience multiple by forcing questions of power/knowledge, responsibility and value that scratch beneath the surface of current resilience fashions.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Critique and ontological politicsDialogues in Human Geography, 2016
- Resilience thinking, fluidity and the agency of a quasi-actantDialogues in Human Geography, 2016
- Resilience multiple – Sounding a call for responsible practiceDialogues in Human Geography, 2016
- The politics of ontology and ontological politicsDialogues in Human Geography, 2016
- Conceptual multiplicity or ontological politics?Dialogues in Human Geography, 2016
- Coordinating and situating resilience multipleDialogues in Human Geography, 2016
- The resilient subject: Exploring subjectivity, identity and the body in narratives of resilienceHealth: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness and Medicine, 2012
- Genealogies of resilienceSecurity Dialogue, 2011
- Apocalypse Forever?Theory, Culture & Society, 2010
- The Body Multiple2002