Effective and ineffective supervision in postgraduate dental education: a qualitative study
- 12 August 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 17 (1) , e142-e150
Abstract
Introduction: Research suggests that students' perceptions should be considered in any discussion of their education, but there has been no systematic examination of New Zealand postgraduate dental students' learning experiences. This study aimed to obtain in‐depth qualitative insights into student and graduate perceptions of effective and ineffective learning in postgraduate dental education.Methods: Data were collected in 2010 using semi‐structured individual interviews. Participants included final‐year students and graduates of the University of Otago Doctor of Clinical Dentistry programme. Using the Critical Incident Technique, participants were asked to describe atleast one effective and one ineffective learning experience in detail. Interview transcripts were analysed using a general inductive approach.Results: Broad themes which emerged included supervisory approaches, characteristics of the learning process, and the physical learning environment. This paper considers students' and graduates' perceptions of postgraduate supervision in dentistry as it promotes or precludes effective learning. Effective learning was associated by participants with approachable and supportive supervisory practices, and technique demonstrations accompanied by explicit explanations. Ineffective learning was associated with minimal supervisor demonstrations and guidance (particularly when beginning postgraduate study), and aggressive, discriminatory and/or culturally insensitive supervisory approaches.Conclusion: Participants' responses provided rich, in‐depth insights into their reflections and understandings of effective and ineffective approaches to supervision as it influenced their learning in the clinical and research settings. These findings provide a starting point for the development of curriculum and supervisory practices, enhancement of supervisory and mentoring approaches, and the design of continuing education programmes for supervisors at an institutional level. Additionally, these findings might also stimulate topics for reflection and discussion amongst dental educators and administrators more broadly.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Otago Faculty of Dentistry Research Scholarship Award
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- The academic environment: the students’ perspectiveEuropean Journal of Dental Education, 2008
- Sound, Presence, and Power: “Student Voice” in Educational Research and ReformCurriculum Inquiry, 2006
- Assessment of the undergraduate medical education environment in a large UK medical schoolHealth Education Journal, 2006
- Climate studies: can students’ perceptions of the ideal educational environment be of use for institutional planning and resource utilization?Medical Teacher, 2005
- Students' Perceptions of Educational Environment: A Comparison of Academic Achievers and Under-Achievers at Kasturba Medical College, IndiaEducation for Health, 2004
- Educational Environment in Traditional and Innovative Medical Schools: A Study in Four Undergraduate Medical SchoolsEducation for Health, 2004
- Student Feedback [1]Quality in Higher Education, 2003
- Authorizing Students’ Perspectives: Toward Trust, Dialogue, and Change in EducationEducational Researcher, 2002
- AMEE Medical Education Guide No. 23 (Part 1): Curriculum, environment, climate, quality and change in medical education–a unifying perspectiveMedical Teacher, 2001
- Putting Students at the Centre in Education ReformJournal of Educational Change, 2000