Abstract
This paper examines “the market” as a source of authority in valuation debates. We argue that the market offers two interrelated forms of authority: epistemic and coercive. Markets have epistemic authority insofar as prices are interpreted as unique measures of otherwise unobservable preferences. In turn, markets have coercive authority because making economic decisions according to market prices is understood to be obligatory. Invoking the authority of the market thus diffuses responsibility from the actor to the market. We illustrate the use of the market as a source of authority in two cases: the exclusion of unpaid housework from calculations of gross domestic product and employers’ pay-setting practices. National income statisticians argue that the absence of market prices for housework renders housewives' true economic value uncalculable. Employers interpret a candidate’s past salary as “the market price” indicating that individual's value, and thus use salary history as the basis for salary offers. These cases illustrate the importance of treating the market as a cultural object and, in particular, as a potent form of justification in debates over value.