A Robust and Unified Framework for Estimating Heritability in Twin Studies using Generalized Estimating Equations
Preprint
Abstract
The development of a complex disease is an intricate interplay of genetic and environmental factors. "Heritability" is defined as the proportion of total trait variance due to genetic factors within a given population. Studies with monozygotic (MZ) and dizygotic (DZ) twins allow us to estimate heritability by fitting an "ACE" model which estimates the proportion of trait variance explained by additive genetic (A), common shared environment (C), and unique non-shared environmental (E) latent effects, thus helping us better understand disease risk and etiology. In this paper, we develop a flexible generalized estimating equations framework ("GEE2") for fitting twin ACE models that requires minimal distributional assumptions; rather only the first two moments need to be correctly specified. In addition, we prove that two commonly used methods for estimating heritability, the normal linear mixed effects model (LMM) and Falconer's method, can both be fit within this unified GEE2 framework, which additionally provides robust standard errors. Given non-normal data, we show that the GEE2 models attain significantly better coverage of the true heritability compared to the traditional LMM and Falconer's methods. Finally, we demonstrate that Falconer's method can consistently estimate heritability even when the total variance differs between MZ and DZ twins; whereas the LMM will produce biased estimates in such settings.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Applying Multivariate Discrete Distributions to Genetically Informative Count DataBehavior Genetics, 2015
- A Genome-Wide Association Study of Behavioral DisinhibitionBehavior Genetics, 2013
- The Minnesota Center for Twin and Family Research Genome-Wide Association StudyTwin Research and Human Genetics, 2012
- Psychometric and Genetic Architecture of Substance Use Disorder and Behavioral Disinhibition Measures for Gene Association StudiesBehavior Genetics, 2010
- Improving Heritability Estimates with REMLNeuroImage, 2009
- Mixed-Effects Variance Components Models for Biometric Family AnalysesBehavior Genetics, 2005
- Fitting Genetic Models to Twin Data with Binary and Ordered Categorical Responses: A Comparison of Structural Equation Modelling and Bayesian Hierarchical ModelsBehavior Genetics, 2003
- Variance components analysis for pedigree-based censored survival data using generalized linear mixed models (GLMMs) and Gibbs sampling in BUGSGenetic Epidemiology, 2000
- The Generalised Estimating Equations: An Annotated BibliographyBiometrical Journal, 1998
- Methodology for Genetic Studies of Twins and Families1992