Benefits and costs of the IESWTR

Authors:
  • SRStig Regli
    Stig Regli
  • RORosemarie Odom
    Rosemarie Odom
  • JCJohn Cromwell
    John Cromwell
  • MLMike Lustic
    Mike Lustic
  • VBValerie Blank
    Valerie Blank

Abstract
This new rule's costs are likely to be outweighed by its benefits, including reduced endemic risk from exposure to Cryptosporidium and improved public health.Like the Stage 1 Disinfectants/Disinfection By‐products Rule, the Interim Enhanced Surface Water Treatment Rule (IESWTR) grew out of the negotiated rulemaking the US Environmental Protection Agency convened in 1992–93 under the Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA). The rulemaking sought to develop a consensus approach to simultaneously addressing potential health risks posed by disinfection by‐products (DBPs) and waterborne pathogens. Even though the process was complicated by (1) the possibility of making inadvertent risk–risk tradeoffs between protection from DBPs and protection from pathogens and (2) uncertainties affecting the assessment of both risks, the regulatory‐negotiations committee was able to devise a well‐balanced, staged approach to regulation. A second FACA committee finalized the approach in 1996–97. This article summarizes the microbial side of the benefit–cost analysis and the explicit uncertainty analysis that was used to inform the stakeholders and the negotiators.

This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit: