Mothers on trial: how Israel's welfare state disqualifies marginalized women's motherhood
Author:
- 1 September 2026
- conference paper
- Published by Free International University of Moldova
- p. 267-280
Abstract
In Israel's welfare state, the motherhood of marginalized mothers, primarily women heading single-parent households, is routinely put on trial: their fitness as mothers is adjudicated by welfare and legal systems that hold the power to remove their children from the family home, justified on the grounds of physical danger and neglect. Yet research on "out-of-home placement" and "single-parent motherhood" largely ignores this phenomenon, and a critical analysis of the relationship between out-of-home placement policy and the disqualification of marginalized women's motherhood remains overdue. This article addresses that gap. It examines the meaning of motherhood in the Israeli welfare state and the centrality of social and governmental mechanisms, primarily the welfare and legal systems, in constructing and positioning it within gendered, class-based, and political power structures. Drawing on three case studies in which "unfit" motherhood was adjudicated in court, the analysis argues that the concept of motherhood is deployed flexibly according to the needs of governmental and public power systems, and that the overt discourse emphasizing the value of biological motherhood is often contradicted in practice. Mothers' custody over their children can be challenged with relative ease, particularly when they belong to marginalized groups who struggle to defend themselves against institutional intervention and the restriction of their parental rights. The article further suggests that behind the accepted justifications for out-of-home placement policy lie broader political, institutional, and cross-class interests that shape decisions concerning the removal and placement of children from marginalized families, a possibility that research in this field has largely avoided confronting. Building on the author's critical studies of the welfare state since the 1990s (Hertzog, 1991; 1996; 2004; 2014; 2021), which emphasized the bureaucratic aspects and power/control dynamics inherent in welfare systems and institutions, the article calls for a critical examination of the structural forces that place marginalized mothers perpetually on trial.This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Minors' Welfare and Bureaucratic Violence in IsraelAnthropology of the Middle East, 2014
- Voices in the Adjudication of Compulsory Adoption in Israel: The Hegemonic Voice of the Professional Expert and the Unheard Voice of the Biological ParentsAdoption Quarterly, 2011
- Toni Morrison and Motherhood: A Politics of the Heart2004
- Organizational Forms as Moral Practices: The Case of Welfare DepartmentsSocial Service Review, 2000
- Performing absence: The staged personal narrative as testimonyText and Performance Quarterly, 2000
- The Extended Case MethodSociological Theory, 1998