Cooperative Criticism: When Criticism Enhances Creativity in Brainstorming and Negotiation
- 1 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
- Vol. 32 (5) , 1256-1272
Abstract
Long-standing wisdom holds that criticism is antithetical to effective brainstorming because it incites intragroup conflict. However, a number of recent studies have challenged this assumption, suggesting that criticism might actually enhance creativity in brainstorming by fostering divergent thinking. Our paper reconciles these perspectives with new theory and a multimethod investigation to explain when and why criticism promotes creativity in brainstorming. We propose that a cooperative social context allows criticism to be construed positively, spurring creativity without inciting intragroup conflict, whereas a competitive social context makes criticism more divisive, leading to intragroup conflict and a corresponding reduction in creativity. We found support for this theory from a field experiment involving 100 group brainstorming sessions with actual stakeholders in a controversial urban planning project. In a cooperative context, instructions encouraging criticism yielded more ideas and more creative ideas, whereas in a competitive context, encouraging criticism yielded fewer ideas and less creative ideas. We replicated this finding in a laboratory study involving brainstorming in the context of a union-management negotiation scenario, which allowed us to hold constant the nature of the criticism. Taken together, our findings suggest that the optimal context for creativity in brainstorming is a cooperative one in which criticism occurs but is interpreted constructively because the brainstorming parties perceive their goals as aligned.Keywords
This publication has 116 references indexed in Scilit:
- Destructive Criticism Revisited: Appraisals, Task Outcomes, and the Moderating Role of CompetitivenessApplied Psychology, 2011
- Creative mood swings: divergent and convergent thinking affect mood in opposite waysPsychological Research, 2011
- Effects of Quantity and Quality Instructions on BrainstormingThe Journal of Creative Behavior, 2011
- A Reexamination of Brainstorming Research: Implications for Research and PracticeGifted Child Quarterly, 2005
- Minority dissent and team innovation: The importance of participation in decision making.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2001
- Influence of social motives on integrative negotiation: A meta-analytic review and test of two theories.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000
- Share and Share Alike or Winner Take All?: The Influence of Social Value Orientation upon Choice and Recall of Negotiation HeuristicsOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1998
- The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory.Psychological Bulletin, 1996
- Productivity Loss in Brainstorming Groups: A Meta-Analytic IntegrationBasic and Applied Social Psychology, 1991
- A study of the generation-of-alternatives process in social problem solvingCognitive Therapy and Research, 1980